The first genuinely honest ad for generative AI I've ever seen, from Microsoft / CoPilot
A mediocre white guy sees his non-white colleague getting praised for good work, he asks AI to *literally copy it*, and then he gets all the praise instead:
The first genuinely honest ad for generative AI I've ever seen, from Microsoft / CoPilot
A mediocre white guy sees his non-white colleague getting praised for good work, he asks AI to *literally copy it*, and then he gets all the praise instead:
@ketan geez this is so revealing. I can't believe they did this.
@ketan It’s so revealing that every office-work AI ad seems to endorse the worst asshole behavior in people. Utter neglect, then taking credit for someone else’s work, then bullshitting your way through, all while not caring about the work product, all for the grand goal of making an extra dollar or winning corporate praise…just the worst aspects of humanity.
@drahardja @ketan They know their audience
@drahardja Yeah, Apple Intelligence ads were exactly like that too. "Oops I forgot to read the presentation my colleagues put effort into, I'll ask my Mac to extract three key points to pretend I've read it, I'm such a good person"
@trikuxabi @drahardja Also Claude, "your UNFAIR advantadge" 🙄
@txo_elurmaluta @trikuxabi @drahardja noski dela "unfair", entrenatzeko datuak nola eskuratu dituzten jakinda
@txo_elurmaluta @trikuxabi @drahardja The hand extracts the last human, and it, too, will be replaced.
@drahardja @ketan They know their target audience.
@drahardja
“It’s so revealing that every office-work AI ad seems to endorse the worst asshole behavior in people.”
Fixed that for you! :neobot_3c:
@ketan
@drahardja @ketan in AI's defense, that was their ad strategy as far back as that Excel in an elevator ad.
@ketan jfc, that's shameful shit
@ketan wtf
@ketan I saw this ad last night and thought exactly the same thing!
@ketan I really hope the ad agency meant to do this and Microsoft just didn't get it
@paulcox @ketan I can absolutely imagine some mid-level creative, exhausted from having to shoot down a thousand slop suggestions from "helpful" client execs, deciding to do that. But I can also imagine a whole team of slopaddled dudebros being completely unable to see the heinous racism in their script.
@ketan I think it overstates the quality of AI, it's not going to rise above the level of the mediocre white guy, merely equal what's expected of someone of his ability. His co-worker presumably will have done an incredible amount of work just to get what he got given racial underestimations and all and without AI or stealing someone else's glory out of pure envy and inferiority.
You've just opened up an eloquent description of AI and its users as
*wanker clankers* and *clanker wankers*
SI wanker: So *not* super intelligence?
Me: *So* not super intelligence!
Sorry “#Sports Illustrated”, #SI now stands for #SuperIdiot. 🤷🏻♂️
@ChemicalEyeGuy @johnlogic @ketan I always liked #SI for #SuperficialIntelligence or maybe #SycophanticInsinuation
“Wanker clankers 🤖 and clanker wankers 🧍♂️” is not the kind of ‘bad romance’ that Lady Gaga referred to here: https://youtu.be/qrO4YZeyl0I
It’s more like the prophetic photo that perfectly symbolizes the deadly nexus of #Trump and #Musk (or #Corruption and #BigTech more broadly).⬇️
@ketan
This ad openly sells slop as a tool for the maintenance of white supremacy
@ophiocephalic @ketan That's what it's designed to do, and what they are selling.
@ketan is this parody ad?
@ketan Morally this is somewhere in the ballpark of the car company promising to set "nature lovers free" when they buy the big-ass SUV and have a blast running it roughshod all over the woodland and prairie. At some point the driver stops, gets out and pets a small plant, then gets back in the SUV and floors it. This was from ~20ya.
They straight-faced that one. Good lordy
@ketan Wasn't there a google ad where AI wrote a kid's fan letter to their favourite athlete?
@ketan GFY with your racism... White, black, what a odd way to see the world mate. Stop with this non sensical means of control sh... Why this BS in here ? Stop weaponising melanin.
@JeanZerian @ketan (*fart noise*)
@ketan @drahardja This is satire, right? This is not a real ad or is it?
@finestructure @ketan @drahardja jesus I hope so
@finestructure @ketan @drahardja AI ads are unironically this cringe. My (least) favourite one was by Apple in which a wife forgets her husband's birthday, gets passively upset at her children for remembering and getting gifts, then uses AI to "gift" her husband something like a collage or montage of photos from her phone, something that phones create automatically these days.
@loathsome_dongeater @ketan @drahardja Wow, that sounds terrible. That’s like a digital petrol station bouquet but with even less effort and therefore more of an insult.
@finestructure @ketan @drahardja Poe's Law. As things become more extreme, they become indistinguishable from their own parody.
@ketan Holy shade
@ketan Edgelords
@ketan That really illustrates what AI is doing to our society...
@ketan when we all thought it couldnt get more blatant
@ketan
This is a bit, right? Onion maybe?
@ketan wow
@ketan What's written reflects on the provider possbily. May evoke a response in some. Thus all I have to say on that aspect.
Yet. Irony may occur... The surprise when entry level card readers to generate the work that they previously did. Their 'korporate overlords' and department head gets raise after eliminating the ones portrayed in this content. Yet card readers may not even be utilized as the logs may provide insight on how the task was done.
Use a tool with discretion.
@ketan Fucking Kyle.
@ketan WTAF !??
@ketan His prompt was seriously "make my charts beautiful"? What did the slopbot do? Add more fingers to his mediocre bar chart?
@ketan sorry the Apple Warren one still wins for me on accuracy. https://youtu.be/YP-ukrBVDH8?si=CiGpJSl3wIEY9QUq #ai
@ketan holy fucking shit lmao
what the actual fuck is going on
@ketan
Then Kyle's boss fired Daniel and Kyle and turned to Copilot...
@ketan except he asks it to make his beautiful? I see nowhere that he asks AI to copy the other chart.
@monocularvision @ketan but the narrative and framing make it clear he's doing this after having a neg reaction to peers calling a coworker's beautiful
what is that if not asking ai to replicate what got his peer praised?
@hi_cial @monocularvision
He actually does "copy" the work, bottom roght of the screen you can see what he types.
Cf. https://mastodon.nzoss.nz/@bigblen/117481299155244444
@monocularvision @hi_cial
At 0:18, he tells the AI to analyze the coworker's work and improve his own. It implies that the AI will extract what coworker did and apply it to his document.