If you are using an iPhone and would like to contribute to OpenStreetMap in a very easy and gamified way: @streetcomplete is now out for iOS!
Your contributions will not only improve CoMaps, but a whole range of OSM-based applications:
If you are using an iPhone and would like to contribute to OpenStreetMap in a very easy and gamified way: @streetcomplete is now out for iOS!
Your contributions will not only improve CoMaps, but a whole range of OSM-based applications:
@CoMaps @streetcomplete Yes, fun in the move.
@CoMaps @streetcomplete I've been using StreetComplete for quite a few months now on Android (although not as much recently for lack of time, sorry), and indeed it's a very fun AND useful app. It makes it so easy to contribute to OSM "on the go". Nice to see it ported to iOS. Congrats for your work!
It doesn't *seem* like this data will be used to train military drones in the future, right?
🤔
@CoMaps @streetcomplete It was already available for Android, so Android folks can contribute as well.
@CoMaps @streetcomplete this is surprisingly well made!!
I can finally mark the building across the street as abandoned!
However, I don’t understand how to mark mixed use buildings (shops on lower floor, residential above)
@psoul @CoMaps @streetcomplete maybe long-press it and make a comment with a description alongside an image?
@Idcrafter @CoMaps @streetcomplete
No, the UI in StreetComplete is very clear about what categories of buildings there are. The app is very well made in the way that there are very few hidden menus, none ambiguous ones that unexpectedly require a long press to show up.
On the OpenStreetMaps (OSM) side, It sounds likes there is a "building" tag and a separate "building:use" tag. StreetComplete only has you edit the building tag, i.e. what type of building is this, not how it is used.
@Idcrafter @CoMaps @streetcomplete Oh nevermind, it does say in the small text:
"Apartment Building: houses for multiple families, may have retail outlets on the ground floor"
@psoul @Idcrafter @CoMaps I agree that it's not ideal, but it's not an invention of SC: Information on the map and the way certain things are mapped is organically decided by the people mapping.
@CoMaps @Idcrafter @psoul @streetcomplete and all schools should have apartments above them- with maybe some retail in between.
@psoul @Idcrafter @CoMaps but did you know there's a whole hidden app version? 🙂
@streetcomplete Thank you!!
@streetcomplete @psoul @CoMaps I didn't know of that and it sounds interesting 👀
@Idcrafter @psoul @CoMaps it's a lot to explore, but depending on your level of expertise: Start small :)
@Idcrafter @psoul @CoMaps the custom overlay function can be quite useful... maybe too useful 🙂
@CoMaps @streetcomplete well done!
@CoMaps @streetcomplete
Street complete was the tool that got me really contributing to OSM and it's great to see that it is now accessible by more people.
@CoMaps @streetcomplete Is it possible to turn off the gamification part and don't feel pressured to keep adding things? I just want to be able contribute at my own pace.
Not to mention that the app awards the amount, not the quality of contributions.
@stealthradek @CoMaps well, the notifications for "achievements unlocked" can be disabled:
But what's displayed in the profile cannot be turned off.
@stealthradek @CoMaps ... but eventually you stop caring about the 33th achievement, somehow 🙃
@streetcomplete @CoMaps Thanks for replying! I don't mind achievements, but the last 'n' days count, github style dots tracker, leaderboards etc. are my sticky points and I'd definitely come back if those features were optional/hidden.
There's enough pressure in the world out there, volunteering shouldn't be adding to it.
I just hope you could make this functionality optional at some stage.
@stealthradek @CoMaps interesting. I kinda follow your thought on this, but I basically never look at the profile page, as I don't really gain anything from that 🤷♂️
The only thing I liked to "play" with were the old "bubbles" of the solved quests, it was basically just physics, if you turned the phone :')
I've checked the extended expert edition, and it also has no way to hide the metrics from the profile.
Anyway, noone will judge you in the community if you can or can't contribute.
@stealthradek @CoMaps But I strongly advise against using SC, if this feature stresses you out. That is not the intention, and I hope I speak for everyone in the community if this is nothing doing work for OSM should feel like.
The intention behind the metrics and visualization, as far as I understand was simply to entertain curiosity and add a light level of motivation, by "seeing something is happening" - as most quests just add unrendered details, it's otherwise hard to show anything.
@streetcomplete @CoMaps I appreciate the response and clarification.
I love the interface which makes adding missing tags a breeze and also in a bulletproof way.
I just wish there was a way to use SC as a editor without the gamification features. As such I'll carry on contributing using different interfaces, but I'd definitely want to use SC given how straightforward it is to use quickly on the go.
@stealthradek @streetcomplete @CoMaps StreetComplete is kinda the "Pokemon GO of OSM Editors" with the gamification features, but if you still want to contribute on the go/in the field, you can also consider @everydoor, which is another "simple" editor without any gamification (Android & iOS), or @vespucci_editor, a full-fledged mobile editor (Android only)
@WeirdAlex03 @stealthradek @CoMaps @everydoor @vespucci_editor I went ahead and created a feature request for this, given the feedback I received:
https://github.com/streetcomplete/StreetComplete/issues/7380
@streetcomplete @WeirdAlex03 @CoMaps @everydoor @vespucci_editor Nice one, thank you, I hope it gets implemented.
I get that gamification helps some to get stuff done but I have enough going on in my life to be pushed into volunteering which I'm happy to do without being pushed to :)
@stealthradek @WeirdAlex03 @CoMaps @everydoor @vespucci_editor
The main dev wrote you a response:
https://github.com/streetcomplete/StreetComplete/issues/7380#issuecomment-6822347159
@streetcomplete @WeirdAlex03 @CoMaps @everydoor @vespucci_editor Unfortunate outcome but if this is the direction the app goes so be it. Not planned settles it.
The app forces to participate in leaderboards (even if it is just a position), missing a daily activity leaves a gap in the grid etc.
I'm happy that some people can just ignore it and move on but some can't. And I can't just not look there... 🤷
And no, it's not the same as the OSM account stats as mentioned in the dismissive response
@stealthradek @CoMaps I went ahead and created a feature request for this, given the feedback I received:
https://github.com/streetcomplete/StreetComplete/issues/7380
I found @MapComplete quite nice. Have you tried that?
@mama_me @MapComplete I haven't yet - I'll give it a shot. Thanks for the recommendation!
@CoMaps @streetcomplete maaaybe you went a little too overboard with the achievement dopamine delivery system. Could we request a Less/No Animations mode?
@ellie @CoMaps sure you can, this is the right place:
https://github.com/streetcomplete/StreetComplete/issues
And for the gamification I've created a feature request:
https://github.com/streetcomplete/StreetComplete/issues/7380
@CoMaps @streetcomplete It's very cool. I usually use another, more "professional" app, but this one will make it easy to do some in-depth work.
Bravo!
@CoMaps @streetcomplete Tagging for 3D rendering makes a difference:
First/lat pic: F4map/OSM simple 3D
left/right side of the pics = levels and roof done/not
This needs more color! Roof default should be red/dark
Wall/Roof colours could be a SC quest
I do have a wish to SC: At the addr:street quest the next roots als option below the input.
The two views are different of course. One dif is the view angle: F4 is more tele, S3D more while angle.
https://demo.f4map.com/#lat=49.7163047&lon=11.0919749&zoom=19&camera.theta=71.07&camera.phi=-19.767
https://felispimeja.github.io/osm-simple3d-editor/?server=osm#18/49.716283/11.09198/26.2/76
@streetcomplete @CoMaps
Nice, thanks!
Android only :-/
I wonder if there could be a configuration text file to define quests (filter tagging, dialogue with defaults, validate) plus bitmaps.
If wall/roof: colour not set
UI input by colors as word-list, last used,
NO! Not a motivating UI, code is needed:
A plugin API?
To much phantasie :)
@karlos @CoMaps well, it supports custom overlays, so you can highlight whatever you want, based on tags or missing there of.
It also supports importing a file with quest markers, if you like.
But the wall color and roof color quests, look like normal quests:
And you can obviously always just edit the raw tags yourself if you like.