Login
You're viewing the functional.cafe public feed.
  • Nov 11, 2026, 2:06 PM

    RE: mastodon.social/@meejah/117595

    I'm not going to sign #HumanEmacs because I *want* discussions about LLMs effectiveness in particular with open weight models, for example.

    You can't put the genie back in the bottle.

    LLMs are here to stay. Ignoring their impact without any discussion as proposed on human-emacs.org/ is the wrong approach in my opinion. Blocking is not the best thing here, discussing the terms would be better.

    If not, what's next? Block all people who use hardware where its vendor has some connections to unfair workforce policies? Block all #FOSS contributors whose electricity supplier as a certain amount of nuclear energy?

    It's never black or white.

    I think we've got enough experience with #cancelculture, over-stressed #policitcalcorrectness and similar movements already.

    I acknowledge the good spirit behind it, I disagree on the chosen method.

    YMMV.

    #AI #LLM #openweight #Emacs

    💬 9🔄 5⭐ 0

Replies

  • Nov 11, 2026, 2:20 PM

    @publicvoit "Rejecting your PR because while your 2-line typo fix is clean, your diet wasn't vegan during the commit, making this patch complicit in global injustice and therefore will be auto-closed to maintain project karma."

    💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 11, 2026, 2:27 PM

    @publicvoit I don't think they're saying that at all. My understanding is that they point out that LLMs are a net negative technology and that ethical software projects should not use them. According to Eli, Emacs doesn't care about ethics, so a fork seems the way to go.

    I don't think cancel culture or any of the other terms your threw in your post apply here. It's just a difference in the way free software is understood by each side.

    💬 2🔄 0⭐ 0
  • 💬 1🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 11, 2026, 7:28 PM

    @publicvoit I didn't say that. What I did say is that they consider these technologies a net negative in ethical, social and environmental terms. It makes sense to me, when we're talking ethics and principles, to not have them be open to negotiation, but that is not the same as cancel culture or political correctness.

    Are they taking the “my way or the highway” route? Probably, but it's them who will take the highway if their demands are not met. They're just asking for a reason to stay.

    💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 11, 2026, 5:35 PM

    @josemanuel @publicvoit I'm a bit confused. Emacs doesn't care about ethics. The FSF clearly does care for ethics.
    This sounds a bit like claiming Startrek is to left or to political.
    But that might explain why not so long ago a feature was added to Emacs which only fully works on macos.

    💬 1🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 11, 2026, 7:33 PM

    @thaodan I'm not sure the FSF cares about anything outside the Four Freedoms. To me, the 4F are a gateway to a more ethical stance on software and society in general, but, according to recent first-hand accounts, they are just an end in themselves, which, quite honestly, I find regrettable.

    @publicvoit

    💬 1🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 11, 2026, 11:41 PM

    @josemanuel @publicvoit It is but explains their inaction to promote Foss and copyleft in companies. To this day I wait for a campaign to clear the fud around gpl3.

    💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 11, 2026, 2:41 PM

    @publicvoit I don't share your interpretation at all. I think people discuss LLMs everywhere these days. Once an individual has reached a conclusion and wants to sign up for Human Emacs, then there is no point to discuss LLMs with the other signatories.

    I also don't understand the qualifications you make regarding cancel culture and over-stressed political correctness. To me, not wanting to collaborate with people who have terrible opinions is the most natural thing to do. Sometimes I have to. Sometimes its expedient not to know. But other than that, having values and living up to them is what I expect of everybody and specifically of those I am going to collaborate with.

    💬 1🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 11, 2026, 2:48 PM

    @alex

    > I don't share your interpretation at all.

    Which interpretation? That they don't want to discuss? Made very clear on human-emacs.org/

    > people who have terrible opinions

    That's the point. Who defines what "terrible" means? I don't see any direct connection between people who want to discuss LLMs and "terrible opinion".

    💬 2🔄 0⭐ 0
  • 💬 2🔄 0⭐ 0
  • 💬 1🔄 0⭐ 0
  • 💬 1🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 11, 2026, 5:20 PM

    @tusharhero Ah, so it's a religious thing?

    Well, I never wrote that there aren't problems to discuss here. I just wrote that I do want to discuss and not to pretend LLMs exist.

    Seems that "let's discuss" is some sort of blasphemy to people like you? Interesting.

    💬 3🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 11, 2026, 5:23 PM

    @publicvoit I don't want to engage with your condescending tone. You keep talking to me (and others who have signed it or are sympathetic) in a very demeaning manner. By calling it a religion you are basically saying we haven't thought about this at all. The real reason is we have thought about it a lot and have had debates where your exact points had come up. We came to our own conclusions after those. If you disagree with us, don't sign it.

    💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 12, 2026, 12:23 PM

    @publicvoit

    I hope you can see from @tusharhero 's response, that their position is more than just religious: it is an ouright cult, enamored more with ingroup-preference and outgroup-demonization than with presenting rational justification for their beliefs.

    One clear example: count the number of times the words "theft" or "stealing" are used incorrectly in this thread. Such creation of new definitions and then forcing them on their group is blatant cult behavior.

    💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 12, 2026, 12:28 PM

    @publicvoit

    Those who participate in @tusharhero 's cult have almost always already established themselves as members of another cult, so they've honed their anri-rational behavior in other areas. The most strategically practical thing to do about them is to drive them into the irrelevant backwaters of FOSS, like GNOME and NetBSD, where they can do their infighting, purity-testing, and vocabulary perversion without interrupting real developers. So: introduce LLM-friendly policies on purpose!

    💬 2🔄 0⭐ 0
  • 💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0
  • 💬 2🔄 0⭐ 0
  • 💬 1🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 13, 2026, 3:37 PM
    @publicvoit @fossham @tusharhero I read the comments and determined that it is what was meant.

    LLM's are the purest form of proprietary software and SaaSS - if you support LLM's, you're part of the proprietary software cult.

    Using a LLM to degenerately copy code (or using the copy-paste operation), that are under incompatible and proprietary licenses, stripping off the attribution and license, always results in proprietary software.

    I predict;
    - All LLM companies are going to go broke (it is mathematically impossible for that not to happen, unless a US governmental bailout was to happen) and therefore the only LLM models that are practical for degenerately copying code will become unavailable.
    - A bunch of software companies are going to acquire the LLM chat logs and work out who copied/translated what proprietary software into other software.
    - Many of such cases of copyright infringement will be prosecuted.

    All of such can be avoided if projects simply remain free software and develop properly, instead of falling for proprietary software and SaaSS *again*.
    💬 1🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 13, 2026, 5:58 PM

    @Suiseiseki

    You did not "determine what was meant" by asking me what I meant. You "determined" it by just making it up without evidence.

    Your irrationality here has a formal diagnosis: it's called "straw man fallacy," and it's employed by people in cults when those outside of the cult point out what they've gotten wrong.

    Your facts are all incorrect too: LLMs can be, and often are, used to write software under free-and-open-source licenses. Your claims all appear to be false today.

    💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 14, 2026, 11:11 AM
    @fossham If a developer was to go and copy a bunch of code from online and proceed to delete the license notices and not attribute and then distribute the combination, the result is not free software.

    The result is proprietary software, because the program infringes copyright and therefore nobody gets the 4 freedoms.

    Using a LLM to do the same thing results in proprietary software.
    💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0
  • 💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0
  • 💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0
  • 💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 11, 2026, 3:15 PM

    @publicvoit I don't share your interpretation of the text on the web page. You say it's very clear on the page and yet we disagree.

    The Human Emacs project is for the people who have already discussed LLMs and have reached the conclusion that they don't want to use LLMs, nor their products. Therefore, do not sign on and then discuss the LLMs. Sign up if you are already convinced.

    If you want to discuss LLMs, no problem. Don't sign up. But Human Emacs is not "ignoring their impact without any discussion". We have been discussing LLMs for years. It's all around us. It's inescapable. Surely there must be a place somewhere for the people who have reached the conclusion that they don't want LLMs in their Emacs.

    As for "terrible": Of course it's a value judgement. But it being a value judgement does not result in inability to judge. If you don't see how LLMs are terrible, then you have reached a different conclusion than other people. Which is fine. But these other people still get to act upon the conclusion they reached, obviously. People disagreeing with each other and acting upon this disagreement is all around us.

    I understand that if you don't see how LLMs are terrible then everything that follows makes no sense. As for myself, I've kept a long list of bookmarks over the last few years. Every now and then I still add new links. I think it would be fair to say that clearly there are some people who think that LLMs are terrible, even if you don't share this opinion.

    💬 1🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 11, 2026, 5:16 PM

    @alex
    > I don't share your interpretation of the text on the web page. You say it's very clear on the page and yet we disagree.

    I wrote that they don't want discussions.
    They wrote: "We are not here to discuss ..."

    I am really puzzled how we could disagree here. 🤷

    💬 1🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 11, 2026, 5:30 PM

    @publicvoit You wrote at the top: "Ignoring their impact without any discussion as proposed on human-emacs.org/ is the wrong approach in my opinion." I claim that this implies a place and a time, not a general refusal of the discussion. Human Emacs is the organization for those of us who have had the discussion and made up our mind. I don't understand what's so weird about that. Every organization with a goal wants to further the goal and not have it undermined all the time. You don't join an org to discuss the basic tenets of the org. Instead, join a different org.

    💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0
  • benbenjamineskola@hachyderm.io
    Nov 11, 2026, 3:45 PM

    @publicvoit

    > LLMs are here to stay.

    so is asbestos but we don't have to make the problem worse.

    💬 1🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 11, 2026, 5:23 PM

    @benjamineskola Well even asbestos is an existing reality.

    So we do have to discuss how to deal with asbestos and quite frankly where I live, this is an ongoing discussion.

    The current letter explicitly wants to avoid any discussion. Which I do find a pity because without a real discussion, all the negative aspects will get continued without any impact.

    💬 2🔄 0⭐ 0
  • benbenjamineskola@hachyderm.io
    Nov 11, 2026, 5:29 PM

    @publicvoit Dealing with asbestos is an ongoing problem, yes; but I don’t think there’s any debate over whether this should be done. Nobody is advocating for more asbestos, only how best to remove it (and perhaps when it should be ignored rather than removed).

    I’m sure other people have pointed this out to you already but the reason that Human Emacs says ‘no discussion’ is that the discussion has already happened. There are many many people who have already done more than enough thinking about LLMs and discussing LLMs and there remains nothing more to say about it.

    That is to say: some people might still wish to debate, but one also needs to account for the fact that there are also people who have seen all the evidence they need to see and are not open to more attempts to persuade.

    The demand for endless debate is frankly disrespectful and insulting IMO. It assumes that anti-LLM positions are not based in reasoned judgment and are always open to being revoked if only the pro-LLM person can be allowed to make their case just one more time. But it’s never a new case, it’s always the things we’ve heard over and over and considered and rejected.

    So, if you haven’t made up your mind yet, fine, don’t sign the petition. But the project leadership needs to understand that some people already have made up their minds.

    💬 1🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 11, 2026, 9:55 PM

    @benjamineskola @publicvoit

    > Nobody is advocating for more asbestos, only how best to remove it

    I may be dating myself a little, but just under 20 years ago, people I know in a certain country definitely were pushing back on the anti-asbestos messaging. It was not banned there, and they were saying the damage can be contained (i.e. you can build with it and not harm those who occupy).

    💬 1🔄 0⭐ 0
  • benbenjamineskola@hachyderm.io
    Nov 11, 2026, 10:11 PM

    @beetle_b Oh sure. I don’t doubt that it happened; leaded petrol too. But we’ve moved beyond that for the most part and actively advocating for them is the realm of cranks. My point is mainly that we can invent things and still decide for the most part not to use them. ‘Here to stay’ is sort of technically true in that the knowledge is nearly impossible to get rid of; but that doesn’t mean the thing in question needs to be actively produced or easily accessible etc.

    And hopefully we can soon reach the point where using LLMs for everything is widely accepted to be a crank opinion.

    @publicvoit

    💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 11, 2026, 9:41 PM
    @publicvoit@graz.social
    Which I do find a pity because without a real discussion, all the negative aspects will get continued without any impact.
    Oh, I suppose this is applicable to ... everything 🙂. When people stops to discuss, then it opens a wide door to any negative aspects. The history full of such examples, like people from Spain didn't discuss the regime of Franko after it's fall and the related problems persisted till 2010 IIRC. Or people didn't discuss the regime of Hitler after it's fall, so it was necessary to wait till the new generated was raised, and than this generation started to asking questions and making a discussions, and only then things changed. Etc...

    CC: @benjamineskola@hachyderm.io
    💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0
  • 💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 11, 2026, 4:38 PM

    @publicvoit You’re completely ignoring the copyright issues which lead e.g. to the AI policy of GCC. This is not about “is this tool good?” or “is this tool ethical?” but about tainting copyright. So comparing this to cancel culture is … not really honest.

    💬 2🔄 0⭐ 0
  • 💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0
  • 💬 1🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 11, 2026, 8:16 PM

    @thaodan @js @publicvoit I think discussion is very important to sharpen one's own view and attitudes of communities. Good reasoning helps a lot here. Declining a thing because it exists is as helpful as declining a position about a thing because it exists. We should assume about each other that we do have way more reasons than "I'm against it, because it exists". Starting with that attitude, imho that's the part where discussions become interesting.

    💬 1🔄 1⭐ 0
  • Nov 13, 2026, 1:42 PM

    @lazarus @js @publicvoit I agree with this point.
    It's just often tend to push when one criticises their shoot first ask later approach.
    Maybe because they feel like one attacks their personal position so they feel as it is their own self they have to defend? From my autistic point of view this kind of personal defense always has been odd to me.

    💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 11, 2026, 5:56 PM

    @publicvoit to me, "cancel culture" is a right-wing inflammatory term trying to discredit valid critique as an attempt to silence people. The text on the Human Emacs website does not call for any particular person to be chastised. Neither does it make any threats or implications about people who have other opinions. They are simply not mentioned at all. Please point out any snippet in the text that you would interpret differently.

    💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 11, 2026, 9:48 PM
    @publicvoit@graz.social
    If not, what's next? Block all #FOSS contributors whose electricity supplier as a certain amount of nuclear energy? It's never black or white.
    Well, if this will happen then possibly my small contributions to FOSS is doomed 😀

    // Looking at the nuclear power plant on the other side of gulf with a lots of reactors powering my city and two districts near it

    BTW, I already saw some ... things before, when some opensource projects was forced to remove it's contributor(s) because someone found some controversial thoughts of this/these contributor(s) in their personal blogs of Twitter. So, possibly the point of no return for these projects (and maybe for the whole opensource) already passed...
    💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 12, 2026, 8:51 AM

    @publicvoit Exakt auf den Punkt gebracht. Wer sich hinter strikten Bannern und moralischem Ausschluss versteckt, verweigert sich der realen Auseinandersetzung.

    Genie und Flasche, die Technologie ist da, und sie zu ignorieren oder reflexartig zu verbieten, löst kein einziges Problem. Wo zieht man die Grenze? Wenn man konsequent sein will, müsste man bei Hardware, Lieferketten und Infrastruktur sofort den Stecker ziehen.

    Statt Cancel Culture und ideologischem Purismus braucht es sachliche Debatten über Bedingungen, Open-Weight-Modelle und reale Handhabung. Völlig d’accord: YMMV.

    💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0