@publicvoit Dealing with asbestos is an ongoing problem, yes; but I don’t think there’s any debate over whether this should be done. Nobody is advocating for more asbestos, only how best to remove it (and perhaps when it should be ignored rather than removed).
I’m sure other people have pointed this out to you already but the reason that Human Emacs says ‘no discussion’ is that the discussion has already happened. There are many many people who have already done more than enough thinking about LLMs and discussing LLMs and there remains nothing more to say about it.
That is to say: some people might still wish to debate, but one also needs to account for the fact that there are also people who have seen all the evidence they need to see and are not open to more attempts to persuade.
The demand for endless debate is frankly disrespectful and insulting IMO. It assumes that anti-LLM positions are not based in reasoned judgment and are always open to being revoked if only the pro-LLM person can be allowed to make their case just one more time. But it’s never a new case, it’s always the things we’ve heard over and over and considered and rejected.
So, if you haven’t made up your mind yet, fine, don’t sign the petition. But the project leadership needs to understand that some people already have made up their minds.