@jason @0xabad1dea @whitequark yes, raytracing offers some pretty important improvements to the pipeline that will (once games can reasonably start to require raytracing hardware) allow for a lot more ergonomic lighting setups, and so raytracing does present a meaningful improvement from that perspective. and good raytracing does look good! when i upgraded my GPU while playing Control and turned on raytracing, the new reflections felt incredible
and don’t get me wrong, i have a 3080 because i do appreciate when things look good
but i also grew up with a GBA and a N64, then gamecube, then wii. i had a laptop with, idk, a GTX 760M or something in it as a kid. i still play SNES games often, and lots of games in that style. games look better and (arguably) run better these days on modern hardware, but if i compare against everything i’ve used, everything i’ve played, the more realistic and dynamic graphics just don’t matter to me, not in the sense that i think games are significantly better off for it than they were a decade ago, and not in the sense that i think better and more accessible raytracing is gonna push it forward that much either
in sum, my thesis is that Super Mario World is the perfect game and every day we stray further from its ideal,