Login
You're viewing the sfba.social public feed.
  • Aug 8, 2026, 8:17 AM

    This characterization of Expertise in Popular Economics is still very apt, I think; it was written nearly two centuries ago.
    (The original is at the bottom of the post.)

    ... in Adam Smith was his diploma;
    our deep economist had got
    the gift of recognizing what
    a nation’s wealth is, what augments it,
    and how a country lives, and why
    it needs no gold if a supply
    of _simple product_¹ supplements it.
    His father failed to understand
    and took a mortgage on his land.

    This is from Pushkin's _Eugene Onegin_, a part of the introduction of the titular character (Chapter One, stanza VII).

    This is a very serious book, but at the same time there are pinches of sarcasm throughout; let the reader pay attention.

    I just picked the first translation at hand and it happened to be Charles Johnston’s from 1977 (as published by Alfred A. Knopf in the US, sixth printing; page 16).
    Unfortunately, I have misplaced my copy of Douglas Hofstadter’s translation (there are quite a few English translations overall, perhaps about ten).

    For comparison, here is a non-poetic literal translation:

    ... However, he read Adam Smith
    And was a deep economist,
    That is, he was capable of judgement on
    The way a nation gains wealth,
    And what it lives on, and why
    It needs no gold,
    As long as it has _simple product_¹.
    His father could not understand him
    And used lands as collateral.

    Pushkin’s original:

    ... Зато читал Адама Смита
    И был глубокий эконом,
    То есть умел судить о том
    Как государство богатеет,
    И чем живет, и почему
    Не нужно золото ему,
    Когда оно _простой продукт_¹ имеет.
    Отец его понять не мог
    И земли отдавал в залог.

    _________
    ¹ The precise meaning of “simple product” (простой продукт) is obscure; it may refer to concepts of late-18th-century French economics.

    #Economics
    #EugeneOnegin
    #PopularEconomics
    #PushkinQuote

    💬 0🔄 1⭐ 0