RE: https://chaos.social/@kfh/117641235012463230
This is an amazing bit of scope creep. Revealing any hidden phones taken in to an exam.
RE: https://chaos.social/@kfh/117641235012463230
This is an amazing bit of scope creep. Revealing any hidden phones taken in to an exam.
Apparently, sending the emergency alert caught 49 people who had their phones on them.
https://en.yna.co.kr/view/AEN20261119010251315?section=national/national
@Edent This is why we often pre-warn people in domestic abuse situations to power off phones before nationwide emergency alert tests. Abusive partners may control their "main" phone, and they might have a second one hidden away for seeking help.
@Edent The scope creep is exactly why I disabled all emergency alerts with GrapheneOS.
I wouldn't have done that if I thought the system would be used properly, but in practice it just gets abused, undermining the entire purpose of it. I'd rather not have the living daylights scared out of me over something silly.
@dfstarshine @Edent 99% of them are useless anyway.
@dfstarshine @Edent Exactly
@ras
At least in Czechia, the cell broadcast system used to be used for little things like telling you the name of the city you might be in or nearby. It was most often displayed as a small insignificant line on the home screen. Of course, with prevalent GPS in phones and UI changes brought with Android and iPhoneOS, this fell out of favor.
Emergency alerts are already the scope creep.
@dfstarshine @Edent
@ozzelot @ras @dfstarshine @Edent
Weird. In Spain it is used only for emergencies and meteorologic red alerts.
Let's hope that nonsense is not contagious.
@jcurioso
I don't know if Czechia currently uses it at all (and I also have it disabled)
@ras @dfstarshine @Edent
@ozzelot @ras @dfstarshine @Edent
It is being enforced by the EU. According with https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EU-Alert, Czechia has an old SMS based system and they are changing it to the modern EU-Alert cell based system.
@jcurioso
exists != is used...
still, interesting to know
@ras @dfstarshine @Edent
@ozzelot @ras @dfstarshine @Edent
Clearly, some countries are abusing the system, others ignoring it.
In Spain, when the leftist government implemented it, it was very criticized by the right; they said it was Orwellian and other nonsense. Then, when there was a catastrophe and the right wing local government didn't use the system until hundreds of people drowned, they stopped criticizing and started using it.
Politicians are weird.
@ras
Surely the ratio of abuse must depend on where you are. I think I have only once or twice seen an emergency alert in the past decade where I am.
IIRC, it was an abuse.. I think something like “support Ukraine”. But probably entailed a security breach that could not be regarded as the norm.
@dfstarshine
Does GrapheneOS suppress the alert entirely, or just the audible?
I seem to recall that it freaked me out. At 1st I thought my dumb phone was hacked. (I would never have a smartphone with GSM radios on)
But in the end I was glad to receive the alerts just out of academic interest in seeing that the alert system was compromised. I would only want to disable it if the abuse were to become a pattern.
@bojkotiMalbona @ras @Edent When the alerts are turned off it suppresses the alert entirely, you don't see or hear anything. GrapheneOS lets you turn off all the emergency alert levels whereas regular Android only lets you turn off everything but the "Presidential Alert" level I believe.
@dfstarshine @Edent Ditto. UK government recently abused the system during the hot summer, using it to send a general message of "please don't accidentally set fire to the country".
I knew they'd abuse the system, so had already disable all these alerts. They also send out test alerts twice a year which I'm happy to not allow to turn my phone into a siren.
@happyborg @Edent Yeah, I remember that, a lot of people on here were talking about it at the time. I had alerts disabled by then so never got it and I felt pretty vindicated.
@Edent Some might call it abuse of intended purpose...
You'd not be surprised at all how often the phone during an exam thing happens in the US.
You can spot it when they come back from the bathroom and start frantically writing, when they were absolutely dead pan before the Lou.
@Edent Yay, a system which people already ignore too much because of alert fatigue - let's send out more useless spam.
Which also hits what, millions of people, to catch a very small number?
In Latvia, they complain that people ignore these warnings, so they have... an ad campaign. Not as bad as the on the in the story, but pretty silly nevertheless.
@Edent Oooh! Oooh! I've got an even better emergency-alert scope-creep alert-blindness-stampede story! My historic institution scrambled to implement a security-theater text-alert system in the late 2000s as their non-response to a spate of deadly mass shootings at similar campuses.
That administration was subsequently found to have repeatedly protected a high-volume serial child rapist because he was a genius at designing defensive schemes in gridiron football. Many other embarrassing revelations followed, including that many years of federally-mandated annual reports of sexual assault and other violent crimes had never been produced.
In desperation to demonstrate to a cable sports network that they were leaving no stone unturned in their public displays of compliance bullshit, that administration decided that each time a sexual assault was reported on campus there would be, that same day, an emergency text alert blasted out to the entire community in the spirit of self-flagellating fear-mongering openness
@IAmDannyBoling @Edent SPOILER ALERT: there were a lot of sexual assault report emergency alerts, all the time
@Edent the UK government did a run with zero warning about wildfires, we were driving and nearly crashed the sound was so shocking. As bad as wildfires are, if it's blanket national rather than targeting, it is totally counterproductive. You remind me i need to look into how to disable this
@sheislaurence Why would you get a warning about an emergency? Given that you didn't actually crash, turning it off seems counterproductive.
@Edent not sure I understand the comment, are you suggesting that only serious accidents justify wanting to opt out? The crash was a very near call and we were all shook up by it.
It seems to me the healthier bar would be 'is this emergency call useful or not'. As many people suggest in comments, trial runs, irrelevant or overreaching messages (an alert about a wildfire happening in Scotland for London drivers, a check on a school exam i am not attending) are totally legit reasons to opt out.
@sheislaurence no. I'm saying that if there had been a genuine emergency, your driving reaction would have been the same.
But if you'd opted out, you would have no way of knowing why other drivers were suddenly behaving erratically.
By all means opt out, I don't have any power to stop you. I just think it is an unwise reaction to something relatively mundane.
@sheislaurence @Edent was that the one that said, "please don't use disposable barbecues"?
Because that really was not an emergency alert. That was an infomercial, sent over the emergency alert system. It was also the reason I switched off everything but the highest level of alert.
@jetlagjen @Edent that was the one. The siren was so loud I thought it was a major fault on the car and something was about to explode. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cwy4zepzp7eo
@sheislaurence @Edent we were in the pub having lunch. At first we thought it was the fire alarm.
@Edent Using the national disaster alert to catch exam cheaters is genius and terrifying in equal measure. It worked too: 22 phones caught ringing in exam rooms. A system built for earthquakes is now a proctor. #SouthKorea #CSAT #Privacy
@NYYANKEES have you got a source for that? I can't find anything.
@Edent Sure! Yonhap reported it: 22 test-takers were caught with unsubmitted smartphones after the disaster alert sounded them off.
@Edent I'm not amused by this misuse of EAS.
@BalooUriza You should write to the Korean government to express your displeasure.
Probably they will not listen. In here (S. Korea) many people (and even one news outlet) showed disabling cell broadcast app will silence the 4370 Message (aka. CMAS Presidental alert / EU Alert 1 / KPAS 0), and expressed concern about its abuse, But the government and ruling party fanboys seems not really interested in this argument. :/
@Edent Quite disturbing to me was the aside at the bottom about the man, who aced the legal test by cheating, who was found dead earlier the day the cheating was discovered - presumably by suicide. These exams feel like very high stakes: People pinning all their life hopes on one test? The government is invested enough in that idea to use the national alert system for a non-emergency? Definitely makes me think about it all.
someone should just have hidden them in the exam hall but off to the sides. Or slipped into the teachers backpack or similar :p
@Edent South Korea generally seems to use cell broadcast a *lot*. During the week we were there last Autumn, we received almost daily messages. Mostly missing person alerts. (To be clear, these were not *emergency* broadcasts, so the phone didn‘t start making the angry alarm sound.)