> But "Australians aren't Germans", MEA national technical manager Matthew Duncan said.
> "Households either won't read the safety instructions or they'll ignore them.
Rude.
> But "Australians aren't Germans", MEA national technical manager Matthew Duncan said.
> "Households either won't read the safety instructions or they'll ignore them.
Rude.
Quick look at the details here. For context this is the dangers of plugin solar I Australia. The max a system can output is 800W. Most households will have 2.5mm cable with 16A or 20A breakers.
There's a couple of concerns which I'll put in replies.
The first concern is that a user has one plug in solar system, that's running at the max output of 800W. So with combined breaker current limit, plus the current from the plugin solar, it's possible to draw over the intended current capacity for the houses wiring for a segment of the cabling.
I don't think this is a huge concern as cabling doesn't instantly catch fire at the rating, most users aren't hitting anywhere the limit of their circuit breaker, and when the solar does turn off from darkness the breaker will trip.
Based on no issues on other countries, this I think is fine.
The other scenario is multiple units plugged in to the same circuit. I don't really feel like like this scenario is likely to cause issues either. The user has to ignore warnings, and then if they do, I suspect you'd need like 4 of these at max output to actually cause a serious incident, which just isn't practical for the people who would be buying and using them. And to cause an issue you'd probably need both 4 of them and a decent load before the breaker.
I haven't done the maths or any experiments but I suspect its one of those things that could be an issue if someone ignored instructions and created a very rare situation.
I guess the question comes down to safety margins. This allows a user to eat into the safety margin. Is someone doing the wrong thing suitable to eat into the margin and by how much?
I think there's enough evidence from other countries that it's not an issue. I'm more concerned of mechanical mounting and panels falling (but that's so minimal to me)
So most electricians are very good at knowing the rules, and following the rules to make installs safe. This is good. You should trust them for doing electrical work.
But engineering the rules, understanding the margins and risk analysis, less so. Their opinions still mater but need to test and validate the concerns.
@xssfox Average Australian reads instructions factoid incorrect. Average Australian has never read an instruction. Instructions Michaela who lives in an instruction manual factory and reads 3000 instructions a day is an outlier and should not have been counted.
@abstractcode @xssfox May I suggest renaming Michaela? "Manuel" is right there...
Edit: or Manuela
@xssfox They aren't wrong though, you seen the average person in a bunnos?
@xssfox Michaela worried other people might get to eat the spicy electrons?
I feel like they should have standardized a power line signalling system that allowed detecting another unit on the same circuit. Though how to get that to work with apartment power being so close, I'm not sure
@xssfox One thing I've seen discussed about running EV chargers off outdoor 10A sockets (although that's starting at 2x the power) is that many older outdoor GPOs have quietly been oxidising for decades, and aren't really ready to run continuously for many hours.
Probably more of a problem at 10A than 3.5A though (and I reckon it's one of the reasons that new cars seem to often come with 6A or 8A slow chargers nowadays.)
@projectgus oh interesting. Curious to know the cause of that.
I suspect if we reinvented power sockets today they'd have thermal fuses built in
@xssfox It's only something I've seen discussed anecdotally, so may not be as much of an issue as it was presented as.
But it kind of makes sense to me that the contacts inside an 40+ year old outdoor outlet may have some resistance that wasn't there when they were clean and new.
@projectgus @xssfox ehh, that's only really a problem when they lose spring pressure which mostly self cleans
@LapTop006 @xssfox That makes sense, possibly I have been misinformed.
@projectgus @xssfox we're also not the US, even our crappier GPOs tend to be better than their decent ones
@projectgus @xssfox
yeah, our ~90s vintage outdoor outlet and plug got what I'd call hot, but not discolouring or melting plastic hot, when charging the Ioniq with its slow charger (1.4kW).
Worse, when we first went to use the Zappi unit (7kW) it kept blowing the breaker, turned out the installers didn't tighten the terminals on the breaker 🤦
@pwarren @xssfox Spicy breaker!
When we got a battery the installers did not initially connect Earth to Neutral behind the breaker box...
Thankfully our EV charger immediately detected this as an earth fault, and after a bit of "nah mate that's some weird problem with your charger, better call the company" they sheepishly acknowledged that they had screwed up pretty bad...
@projectgus @xssfox the car chargers also come with some limitations like the US code only allows drawing 80% of rated capacity for continuous use, and that is likely to contribute to software limiting to 8amp
@lilstevie @xssfox Yeah, it's definitely a safety margin some manufacturers have put in for some reason (and voluntarily in our case!)
@xssfox My first thought was similar to @ThermiteBeGiants' here: https://aus.social/@ThermiteBeGiants/117601290914037416
@projectgus @ThermiteBeGiants ha yes
@projectgus @ThermiteBeGiants my mental worse case picture is someone with 8 of these on power boards floating on their pool powering the pools pump/filter
@xssfox @ThermiteBeGiants yes, shouldn't underestimate the limits of creativity!