The problem with re-playing LA Noire is when you get to the Homicide desk cases. Knowing the twist ending (that every case was actually done by the perpetrator of the Black Dahlia killer, who you secretly take out) all other cases feel hollow and shameful on second play, because you know you are arresting/locking up the wrong person.
It's made worse by the fact that there was SUPPOSED to be a Bunco (fraud) desk you played through before Homicide (you still hear Phelps is being transferred to Homicide after 6 months in Bunco). And, honestly? I suspect the cut bunco cases would have been awesome to see.
That and the potential for a Robbery desk sound much better than having to slog through like 7 brutal murders of women where you don't even lock up the right person each time.
