Login
You're viewing the functional.cafe public feed.
  • Nov 20, 2026, 1:36 AM

    I'm pretty sure you could build a perfectly functional electric car that was purely analogue. No digital electronics at all, just analogue electrical systems and gauges.

    That would be pretty extreme though. In practice you'd probably want to include a decent battery management system at least, and a few standard safety features like ABS, airbags, etc.

    One obstacle to selling simpler vehicles are the car safety testing orgs like ANCAP, who now insist on a long list of active safety systems that require a bunch of computers, cameras and other sensors to implement.

    💬 4🔄 0⭐ 0

Replies

  • Nov 20, 2026, 1:50 AM

    @spacelizard I feel like you could meet the minimum standards from ANCAP and still be able to eliminate a lot of BS and simplify a lot of things.

    And, I'd think that simplifying might also improve battery life and range, simply because the battery doesn't have to supply power to so many things that aren't 'make car move'.

    💬 1🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 20, 2026, 2:29 AM

    @dartigen The problem is that ANCAP ratings (like many other star rating systems) became an all or nothing thing. 5/5 was the expectation and anything less had a major impact on a new car model's sales prospects, especially fleet sales. Car Expert published a critique of the ANCAP situation 3 years ago (carexpert.com.au/opinion/why-a), which I think is still relevant.

    There are signs ANCAP are beginning to take a more pragmatic approach, with the 2026 testing standards marking active safety systems down for false positives and other unnecessary distractions (carexpert.com.au/car-news/tire), but I think it's still difficult for manufacturers to successfully market cars in Australia with anything less than maximum technology.

    I wouldn't expect any measurable improvement in range from reduced gadgets in any case, though. The power required by all the extra electronics is still tiny compared to that used by the motors. There are much bigger efficiency gains to be had by reducing size and weight.

    💬 1🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 20, 2026, 8:59 AM

    @spacelizard @dartigen the false positive penalties are so important, and I’m glad to hear they’re being implemented. I am still sweating from a drive on a Jaguar iPace down a narrow Tasmanian road where a large truck was barreling towards me. I was consequently driving right on the edge of the asphalt but the car kept fighting me and trying to push me into the oncoming truck!!!! Since that experience I am actively hostile to these systems.

    💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 20, 2026, 2:07 AM

    @spacelizard I don't care what bells and whistles they add to cars, as long as a) I can turn off ones I don't want and b) no data AT ALL is shipped outside the car (or if it is, I can turn that off too).

    It's not the features; it's the imposition of them without consent (and often without informing the owner).

    💬 1🔄 0⭐ 0
  • 💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 20, 2026, 3:06 AM

    @dartigen @kauer The imposition was itself demanded by ANCAP. They require a number of active safety systems to be either always on or to reactivate themselves each and every time that the car is turned on.

    For the sake of balance as the owner of a 2023 BYD Seal with the full set of active safety systems I will say that I'm entirely happy with them.

    When Seals first arrived in Australia the Automatic Emergency Braking and Lane Keeping Assist were overly sensitive (presumably to please ANCAP, who have only recently started to penalise false positives), but that was pretty quickly fixed by a couple of software updates and I've not had a problem with them since. Traffic Sign Recognition was always a pointless brain fart but updates added the option to permanently disable alerts from that so it's now a non-issue too. So for most of the time I've owned the car I've been happy to run it with all the safety features turned on, they don't bother me at all. And yes, they do all run locally, no dependency on a data connection beyond the car. The car does have connectivity and an app, which has a few occasionally handy features, but its use is entirely optional and you can just pull out the data SIM card if you want.

    💬 1🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 20, 2026, 3:37 AM

    @dartigen @kauer Personally I classify these things as good or bad automation depending on whether it's a computer supervising a human (e.g. ABS, traction control, AEB) or a human supervising a computer (self-driving tech).

    Having a computer intervene in limited, well defined ways when a human makes a mistake is making best use of the capabilities of both. Conversely having a human passively supervise a computer is a terrible idea, because humans are awful at maintaining continuous attention to something they are not actively involved in.

    Cruise control in its various forms is in the grey zone, I feel. Yes it does involve handing over partial control to the computers, but under the right conditions reducing driver workload is a net benefit. My car has both adaptive cruise control and "intelligent cruise control" (adaptive cruise control plus automatic lane following). I'm happy using the former for highway driving, but I don't use the latter at all because to me that would be a step too far towards passive supervision.

    💬 1🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 20, 2026, 4:29 AM

    @spacelizard @kauer As a learner, I don't mind adaptive cruise control (in the Kona I sometimes get to drive; mostly I'm in a 2000s Suzuki hatchback that doesn't even have cruise control), but I don't end up using it much; I'm in the habit of doing my own braking, so in urban areas it usually gets turned off so often that I just don't bother. If it was an upper limiter instead then I'd probably use it more (or at least not give up on it completely).

    Lane assist has been more frustrating than anything else though, even when it would've been nice in crosswind conditions.

    And honestly, if I was exclusively learning in cars with all the assist technology, I don't know that I'd be able to cope with the driving I'm doing now. I would worry as well about the impact on someone who hasn't had any driving experience without that tech, or with it turned off at least. (At a minimum, all the audio alerts make a one-hour lesson in my instructor's BYD more exhausting than a four-hour drive in the Corolla.) Maybe I'm just the weird one who finds it easier to stay focused if I have to do more, and harder to stay attentive if the car is doing all the work for me.

    I'd like to think that the real-world testing would help to iron out a lot though, because that explains quite a bit. I doubt any roads out there in the real world are anywhere near as well-maintained or designed as a test track, even in major cities. And in a *lot* of products, testing under real-world conditions (and with the real people who will use the product) seems to be a bit of a revelatory concept. (I don't blame regulators for that though - at least, not exclusively. There's also a lot of people in and around product design who need to be regularly reminded that their life experiences are not universal, not everyone lives in cities, etc.)

    💬 1🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 20, 2026, 4:47 AM

    @dartigen @kauer Our previous car (a Hyundai i30) had a speed limiter function. It was great, and I used it a lot more than the (non-adaptive) cruise control that it also had. I miss having that option.

    You're not at all unusual in finding it easier to focus when you're more actively involved, and harder to stay attentive when you're not. That's human nature, and a well recognised phenomena ("automation blindness") that has been implicated as a factor in a number of aircraft accidents. Unfortunately when it comes to cars this issue is being largely ignored, by both manufacturers and regulators.

    💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 20, 2026, 4:25 AM

    @spacelizard we should aspire to meet the safety level of the Proton Jumbuck, where the driver would be impaled through the chest on the steering column in an otherwise minor front-on crash

    💬 1🔄 0⭐ 0
  • 💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0
  • 💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0