Everybody remembers Double Fanucci from the Zork games. Nobody remembers Gabber Tumper.
Double Fanucci was originally described as “a complex, thinking man's version of Gabber Tumper.”
Everybody remembers Double Fanucci from the Zork games. Nobody remembers Gabber Tumper.
Double Fanucci was originally described as “a complex, thinking man's version of Gabber Tumper.”
@zarfeblong It's like the contrast between Poker and Badugi.
"Well actually..."
In Sorcerer (and Planetfall) the game is referred to as "Double Fannucci", with a double N. I don't know which spelling came first, though. Zork Zero tried to have it both ways by referring to it as "Double Fanucci (or Fannucci)".
I remember being disappointed with the Zork Zero implementation of it. I thought I'd be a puzzle, but it turned out to be just an elaborate copy protection.
@et_andersson @zarfeblong I agree in general, but to me, it made sense as a puzzle (assuming that you don't know every info bit from the packaging, useful or not, by heart): first you start playing Double Fannucci, then you realise you can't win, then you look for clues elsewhere and at some point you decide to look through the feelies again, and finally you still have to connect the dots and wait for (spoiler warning!) a Trebled Fromp to be discarded.
@vintrospektiv @zarfeblong But even so, it's a solution that doesn't really make sense to me. I'm just told as soon that my opponent does X, I have an unstoppable win in three moves. I have no idea why this is unstoppable, nor do I know why anyone would ever do X. Particularly when that's apparently the only way to lose, because the points mean nothing.
The game seems to operate on Calvinball rules.
@et_andersson @vintrospektiv The game *does* operate on Calvinball rules. I suppose “Fizzbin rules" is a better term.
It seems like a pretty standard form of information puzzle to me. Having an apparently complex system which is really window dressing is just them having fun.
(I feel like Infocom must have done this kind of puzzle before Zork Zero, but no example is coming to mind. Maybe one of the Douglas Adams games?)
@et_andersson @vintrospektiv My real question is why they called it an “indefensible" gambit, which means the opposite of what they think it does! They should have said "indefeasible”.
@zarfeblong @et_andersson Hah, I never noticed that. I assumed it to mean "gambit that cannot be defended against", which is probably what they also assumed. But you are right, of course.
@zarfeblong @et_andersson I don't think they had a puzzle like that before (at least I can't remember one either), but the standing-in-line puzzle from Ballyhoo matches the type "break out of a loop by doing something unexpected" at a very general level.