So LLMs and layoffs aren’t the root cause, because there is no such thing as a “root cause” here. And maybe they don’t even turn out to be one of the proximate causes.
But if they’re not causes, they’re comorbidities.
9/
So LLMs and layoffs aren’t the root cause, because there is no such thing as a “root cause” here. And maybe they don’t even turn out to be one of the proximate causes.
But if they’re not causes, they’re comorbidities.
9/
I quipped yesterday:
When termites are eating the whole structure, can you identify which single specific beam made it fall?
•That• is the framing I’m advocating in this thread.
10/
So I say yes, do complain about vibe coding, do complain about layoffs, point that finger, mock, cajole, crack those jokes, post those memes — not because everything would be better if only the vibe coding would just vanish, but because it’s a way of drawing attention to the termites in society’s structural wood.
All the meming and gallows humor is good if it is part of recentering and refocusing on humans.
Let’s build and do great things by being kind, by being humane, by never losing sight of the value of the humans who touch and make every part of these messy systems that are breaking so badly right now.
11/
P.S. Apologies to termites, they are cool creatures, this is not an anti-termite account, these pernicious societal forces are way worse than termites; the metaphor works only inasmuch as you don’t want termites eating your home.
Thought along similar lines:
https://thepit.social/@peter/117613573392623125
@inthehands That's a good aphorism, definitely a keeper.
@inthehands 🐜🐜🐜🐜🐜🐜🐜🐜🐜
“What happened to Paul?”
“The termites came for him. Though, to be fair, it is overly simplistic of us to attribute the downfall of Paul’s anti-termite account to this single factor. The reality was a complex interaction of tightly coupled systems led us to throw the least powerful and most disposable parties under the bus: termites.”
@inthehands Makes me wonder if there’s a part of nature where capitalists are beneficial.
We should teach kids "either/and" rather than "either/or" because rarely do systems (and everything breaks down into systems at some point) produce binary choices.
Decisions may be yes or no, but we're more complicated: as people, as systems, and as societies.
@inthehands But stop trying to be good cute and perfect, be natural, loud and laugh without bbeing PC guilty, bring back NATURALNESS so you can bne funny and not tedious and boring..as WELL was working for GOOD!
@inthehands Tangential to what you're saying in this thread, but related: in school, I learned about how individual artisanal crafting of machines gave way to interchangeable parts as things modernized.
As someone in IT, it became very clear that modern software is in tension between the people who write it -- individual artisanal crafters -- and management, who want it to be (or become) interchangeable parts. "AI"/LLMs are the latest iteration of this un-discussed conflict.
@Unlikelylass @inthehands There is also the tension between artisanal crafters and the boring infrastructure they need in order to focus on the artisanal bits.
@Unlikelylass @inthehands The key is that machines are really good at producing the same thing repeatably - and that's fine.
If every line of code, or every method, or class, or program did the same thing, then we would be comparing apples and apples.
The machine part of producing software was mastering CDs and floppies, now it's making assets downloadable.
But crafting the assets? That's what we do. We figure out what is needed and then we design and implement it.
That's what we do.
@rhempel @inthehands I think my point is that the management refuses to acknowledge that part. They desperately want it to just all be interchangeable parts, and continue to act like *this time* the silver bullet (LLMs "ai") will make it behave that way.
@Unlikelylass @inthehands We are in complete agreement, and it has ever been thus :-)
@rhempel @Unlikelylass @inthehands
You can automate production, and you can even automate production of the machines that produce, but at some level you run into a thing that has to be built by a conscious being who is motivated to get it right, or else it probably won't be. (...because there are infinitely more ways to be wrong than to be right.)
The oligarchs and managers always want to believe that whatever piece they're in charge of is one that can be automated.
...and maybe it can be -- but first you need someone to make that automation, and to ensure that it works properly... and you need to keep them around to fix it when it breaks, keep it oiled properly, and presumably update it as the need changes.
(This made sense inside my head; I apologize if the sense got detached on its way out the door.)
@woozle @Unlikelylass @inthehands It's perfectly clear and aligned with what I was trying to express.
Modern Management practices is all about treating *people* as easily replaced interchangeable cogs, whether they be employees, customers, vendors, or legislators.
@Npars01 @Unlikelylass @inthehands
Fungible.
@inthehands https://bsky.app/profile/robertsilverman.bsky.social/post/3n2ab7euyys2i "The problem with having an administration riddled with termites is when something legitimately concerning happens, you can't trust anyone or anything being said."
@inthehands and, importantly, does it make sense to look for which specific terminate caused the beam to fall?
@inthehands
But have any of these #AI "heroes" fixed any of these real world problems?