Login
You're viewing the functional.cafe public feed.
  • Nov 9, 2026, 10:00 AM

    @riverpunk I really liked your post about re-thinking FLOSS, but I think (humbly) you're walking in the wrong direction here. A community is not a McDonalds. It can feel rude because the etiquette is different. If your grandma makes cookies for you and your friends, you can't then say "these are shit cookies" as though you can compare them to fast food. There's no "customer is always right" because there's no customer. There's an expectation that you'll take your plate to the sink, or the kids will help with the setup or cleanup, or a thousand different rules which change depending on where you are, exactly.

    Instead, it works a lot more like "this is your house, you have to do your chores, you have to follow the rules, you have to communicate" (this respect is part of what RTFM is about. Sadly it's applied very disrespectfully by children, but that is / was the goal). As an example here, early on in the Linux Gaming scene, a bunch of gamedevs said (some irately, some thankfully) that most of their bug requests came from Linux users. The idiots thought that all the bugs were in Linux. The smarter ones realised that this was a community pitching in, taking the plates to the sink.

    I think when it comes to community, this kind of soft habit forming is how we keep the community going. The thing we need is more LUGs, more beer, more chats. People bringing their partners, more actual food, potlucks, and on and on.

    And to be clear, my first instinct was to make the same mistake, to suggest better funding models, but this is the same problem, it turns things into the same "capitalism" model. Maybe co-operatives, etc. but not really a true distribution of power and responsibility. In the end it has to come down to each of us.

    So actually my first suggestion is going to be...

    💬 1🔄 0⭐ 0

Replies

  • Nov 9, 2026, 10:13 AM

    @riverpunk GUNS! Not real guns, metaphorical ones.

    See, the thing you'll notice about all the anarchist groups is that they are / were armed. Why do the Zapatistas have guns? Because capitalism is always colonising. You leave a commons and a capitalist will turn up with a fence. So, you need guns. Capitalists turn up? You shoot them. They turn up with an army? You shoot them. Eventually they won't bother, the costs are too high. You also kind of need a moat, something no one would cross. The GPL3 acted like such a moat, a lot of companies wouldn't touch GPL3 code.

    Aside: being able to push capitalists aside also kills the idea of AI in FLOSS software dead. It becomes a strange "why would you do that? Who are we racing? I'm just having fun"

    We need ways to be toxic to capitalists (that includes AI bros). We need the code itself to toxify AI, we want the very names of software projects to be toxic to software companies. Project names which are rude words, or trademarks (no one is going to like importing the "Sony C*nt" library). It needs to conflict badly with commercial entities (DNS entries which aren't using DNS, everything is a torrent, whatever it takes for a regular computer to say "this will destroy your PC")

    💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 9, 2026, 10:18 AM

    @riverpunk Second suggestion: we need to take politics seriously. We need to aggressively pursue our agenda through politics. We need to be annoying AF like the NRA. How will FLOSS devs get paid? UBI. How will communities form? Laws making co-operatives a lot more like non-profits. Free administration, and on and on. Every step should be about empowering the community and stopping proprietary software. We should make a proprietary format straight up illegal, and force governments to use FLOSS formats.

    💬 0🔄 0⭐ 1
  • Nov 9, 2026, 11:33 AM

    @bakuninboys hmm. A few notes. I've included some numbers to break up my disparate thoughts. Feel free to use them as a reference if you decide to respond. Hopefully none of this comes off as too antagonistic.

    1)

    Firstly, I think the point of the whole FOSS thing is to *give regular, non-technical users access to software that lets them liberate themselves*. Really, "liberate" is perhaps a too strong word. Software that lets them choose what they want to do with their computer. Too often, Big Tech offers tech solutions that dictate from the get-go what kind of options you're allowed to pursue with your PC.

    2)

    With that in mind, I don't think it's insane to want to build a model that truly does serve the users in a meaningful way. Grandmas cookies are great because they're just a treat. When you're trying to get tools in the hands of people who can't write their own (specialization is a thing), I think it's fair to say those users ought to be able to look at your offers and tell you what's lacking.

    If you don't want your software to work like that, that's fine, but don't call yourself part of a movement -- clearly you're only doing this as a hobby project.

    3)

    On that note, lets not look at hobby projects in open source as being necessarily the same thing as politically useful software. If your janky little messaging app isn't taking feedback from users on all the ways the UX is confusing and could use improvement, then it's clearly not serving an important function in a movement meant to empower users. You're allowed to release it, but as stated in (2), please do not mistake your project as being part of our movement.

    4)

    Maybe the funding model isn't gonna be the solution to shipping a bunch of features that users provide feedback on, but I don't really know what else would be. I'm all ears, but the current situation seems to be that we are lacking in resources, and my guess is that the best way to increase resources is with funding.

    I don't think money is necessarily an evil thing. The economy is simply the sum total of all human effort. The big question is where we want to be putting that effort. Is it going towards meaningful things or stupid things? If we put money towards open source, that is the best way to direct human effort into open source. Without it, you will only ever get contributions from off-hours in developers' free time.

    If the fear around money and co-ops/non-profits is that the power structure will lead to corruption, then I would suggest we begin with unions and spend much of our time on designing structures that prevent hostile takeovers or Benevolent Dictators For Life. In other words, Democratic, worker-controlled power structures.

    ---

    Is any of this going to be easy, or cheap? No. Is there going to be an obvious path forward for how to actually even ship all of the features users are providing feedback on? Again, no.

    But it seems currently that a lot of voices aren't necessarily interested in even trying to find solutions to those resource problems, and instead think FOSS should just be a hobbyist movement for nerds.

    💬 1🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 9, 2026, 12:17 PM

    @riverpunk So first, not at all, I think we fundamentally want some pretty similar things, and I thank you for taking the time to listen. So for (1), we're notionally in agreement. I think I'm a lot more fundamentalist about what we need to shed, I think tinkering around the edges is how we got into this mess.

    So like, the word "user" functions in the same bucket as "customer", like "a guy walks into a shop", so now, whatever community thing you build, it's already mapped to some transactional thing. Walking into a KFC and walking into a church, same thing. The priest takes your order, gives you a ticket, you pay and eat your body of Christ. It comes in a little paper box along with a plastic toy. The volunteers map to employees, there's a hierarchy. I'm saying maybe the whole shape should be different. (I actually think borrowing liberally from religion or sporting teams is wiser than capitalism)

    So we get to (2) and now we have "professional software" with "business needs", and that can work (eg Blender) but the fact is that people aren't just non-technical, they're also non-political, so asking for community driven software is just not going to work. That's why there's no alternative to the Adobe stack. Really, the professional artist community could have paid software engineers to create FLOSS software. Where is it?

    I also think you're underselling "hobby" projects. It's pretty well known that FLOSS software is way more efficiently written, often less buggy, and just plain better, than proprietary software, to the extent that companies have tried to replicate an "internal OSS model" to try and gain those efficiencies. The trouble has always been: how do we get this "hobby" to scale? How do we get all of us to read each others' code?

    btw an example of "hobby" is libxz. Easy to write off when it works.

    So with that in mind, let's look at (4) without necessarily solving the problem. The issue here is funding as an idea itself. We're not trying to "fund projects" like executives, our actual goal is closer to mutual aid. The trouble there is, *something* isn't working online like it does physically. I say LUGs because I think this is where we lost our way. We need a physical space like a library or a computer shop and there needs to be free food. This is the connective tissue we need.

    And to be clear, I'm speaking in favour of non-profits and co-ops. My point wasn't that money is unnecessary, but that the focus should be on the co-operatives & organisations themselves, the models, what works, how to share that, how to scale it.

    💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0