RE: https://social.treehouse.systems/@ariadne/117579594140229264
If free software is not about ethics, then what the fuck is its point.
RE: https://social.treehouse.systems/@ariadne/117579594140229264
If free software is not about ethics, then what the fuck is its point.
@Gargron no its about championing rampant libertarianism, didn't you know the hippies were all about that? /s
@ShadowJonathan @Gargron That would... not be an entirely inaccurate description of a non-trivial subculture within the hippie movement, fwiw
@Gargron That’s the whole difference between free software and open source, we can thank Eric Raymond…
@tusharhero @Gargron Worse than who ?
he's a misogynist and a homophobe
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eric_S._Raymond#Political_beliefs_and_activism
@tusharhero @benroyce @faket @Gargron
He is the only guy that I have witnessed to include a picture of his guns in a conference talk [Perl Conf, 1997]. His "Open Source" was always his libertarian fever dream.
He is also a huge climate change denier, digging into FORTRAN code to "prove" the models are wrong.
@benroyce @faket @tusharhero @Gargron gosh, that second paragraph is insane
@HannahClover @faket @tusharhero @Gargron
"women exist. therefore they are trying to destroy me"
hardcore misogyny
If the debate is "free software" vs "open source", I guess the point of comparison would be Richard Stallman.
@faket @Gargron "Corporations don't care about freedom" was pretty much the founding motto of Open Source. They -- Eric in particular -- were very explicit that Open Source was about rejecting any ideas of morality in favor of arguments that sharing source code could be very profitable.
The problem is that they won.
@Gargron for me free software has been, can we make a world where everyone has free, same access to software? and an ecosystem where if you don’t like what you see, you can change it.
but if the software you use is built off of trash morals why use it?
edit: muting this thread for my own sanity
@mrkeen @Gargron that's a factual law that governs how the universe works, not something you can choose to not use.
trigonometry is law, there is no way around it. it is definite fact. but the choice of using emacs as your text editor is not :)
looking into this, maybe there should be a general shift to use other names for things like "Pythagorean theorem"
the us constitution was written by slavers, but there's no need to divest from the us constitution
in fact that tool they made evolved to specifically reject slavery
we simply separate the individual personalities from the tool
you could take the view: "well can you drive a tesla knowing you are funding elon musk?"
but all that is required is that it no longer fund musk. you can buy a tesla after he is kicked out of the company
the point is they are not still alive. were they still alive, yes, you reject them
another example:
can you watch and enjoy a woody allen movie?
no, because you're funding/ supporting a pedophile materially. woody is still alive and making movies
we can not partake of the output of a vile person. we can not actively fund/ support a vile person
@benroyce @jpeisach @Gargron
I can't do better than "we the people" is rejected from a live slaver but accepted from a dead slaver.
I got blocked, so best of luck to you.
Two individuals both wrote that they would literally murder their neighbour, but I'm the one that's gotta go!
Anyway, the top-level of this was about LLMs. I expect to see people divesting from Linux any day now! Not to mention github-hosted projects like mastodon. Otherwise,
100% virtue signalling
"Two individuals both wrote that they would literally murder their neighbour"
who said that?
nobody in the thread said that
you're injecting something that only exists in your head into the mouths of other people and pretending they said that
that's *extremely* suspect
you have some sort of cognitive/ social problem that you need to deal with
you introduced the hypothetical
that tells us about your attitude, not anyone else's
if luna takes your ragebait, that doesn't change the fact this idea of killing people is from *your* head, no one else's
also you mentioned "two"
a tactic of edgelord ragebaiters: they get one bite with their trolling and suddenly they are saying "this is the common attitude"
you are *deeply* dishonest and bad faith in your rhetoric
more will block you if you stay this unserious
i'm a wise-ass, but close enough
jackie blocks me. i did not see it
regardless, this is again a reply to *your* comment about killing people
right? my point right above in this thread?
but you just flat out ignore that, and now straight up lie
so you're a lying troll
why do you do this? do you enjoy being dishonest? you get a thrill?
okay
but you've turned yourself into a joke, a clown
you're at best an odd psychological specimen to be amused by. you're certainly not a serious person
@mrkeen grow up and move on. If someone wishes to remove you or your comments on their page- that is their choice and your problem to deal with alone; whining online about it is very childish. You aren't THAT important, sorry.
@tropicalchaos good comment for the top level
@mrkeen it was directed to you solely, but good job not taking in context! You missed the point completely, which takes some effort, I guess.
@benroyce @mrkeen @jpeisach @Gargron that last paragraph is maybe half right: we shouldn't support them and we needn't accept their contributions, but we can replicate the desirable parts of their work and invest them with a different, pro-social ethic
No one "owns" Enlightenment ideals, the Pythagorean Theorem, or the number 5: each has been arrived at and articulated independently of a popular source by people working to solve one or another problem. Software contributions, like national constitutions, are not any flavor of Revelation Divine; their *entity* can - and should! - be excluded from the body politic when their origins and motives are anathema to that body, but the *essential ideas*, when merited, may yet be put to a useful end.
Lots of folks described geometry and human rights and made comedy from their neuroses. Probably the maintainers of a text editor can wait a couple days for someone else to implement Nathan Bedford Forrest's feature list.
@paneerakbari @mrkeen @jpeisach @Gargron
the entirety of human history is "flawed person makes stunning positive contribution to society"
so what we do is we use their advance, and reject the person if their flaw is straight up evil
which excusing slavery or being a pedophile certainly is
@benroyce @paneerakbari @jpeisach @Gargron Yep, and this captures (I believe) RMS's intent with the FSF licenses originally. He used to be accused of communism. These days he's accused of a bunch more shit.
Public opinion can change on a dime. Use the advance, reject the person indeed!
@mrkeen @paneerakbari @jpeisach @Gargron
RMS defended pedophilia
that's not an accusation. that's what he said
so fuck RMS. and fuck people who don't have a problem with slavery. and fuck you and your trolling in defense of these turds
"Public opinion can change on a dime"
not on slavery and pedophilia, you fucking loser chud
@benroyce @paneerakbari @jpeisach @Gargron I'm sorry about all the hostility.
I'm not defending slavers and pedophiles.
I'm defending your choice to use software made by slavers and pedophiles.
You can continue to hang out in GNU-land, and I'm not going to mistake you for an RMS apologist or a pedophilia-normaliser.
@mrkeen @paneerakbari @jpeisach @Gargron
so you switch topics and stopped defending your lying and trolling: you introduced the idea of killing people, then blamed other people for that, by quoting their ragebaited replies
now you try to draw some sort of clarification between pedophiles and slavers, and supporting pedophiles and slavers
dude, you're weak and cringe
why do you do it?
why do you set yourself up to be despised?
why don't you just change and stop being such a cringe loser?
@benroyce @paneerakbari @jpeisach @Gargron I'm on too many threads at once and I guess I'm blocked too. Hard to keep track of. And sometimes I'll just hit one or maybe two items in a five-item reply.
@mrkeen @paneerakbari @jpeisach @Gargron
listen: you got called out on bad faith behavior. the only proper reply to that " i will stop acting in bad faith"
not hemming and hawing and posturing and making it seem like your behavior was innocent
it isn't innocent. it never was. you're transparent and obvious in your methods, and you know it
you're a loser troll. so stop being a such a fucking loser troll
stop replying to me like you still deserve to be treated with respect. you don't
@tusharhero @jpeisach @Gargron I wrote out both alternatives - which did you find problematic?
Pythagoras and trigonometry are not a good comparison to hypothetical slavery in software.
We can't affect what people in the past did. We can improve the world today by choosing not to accept the products of slavery, so that slavery becomes less useful to the slave owners.
Being an apologist or devil's advocate for slavery is not a good look.
@Gargron Eugen Rochko being on the right side of history counter: ∞
@Gargron How is that a ‘yes’..
“We could shoot ourself in the foot but we could also choose not too. We chose yes.”
@stux @Gargron Because for some forms of libertarian “freedom” mainly refers to property and what _they_ can do it with, not what people in general can do. He further goes on to state “it would split the community” if they refused to accept slave created software, as if a ruling that accepting such software isn’t devisive in the first place.
@Gargron Depends on who defines the ethics. I like free software and, personally, I would like to see everything released under more permissive licenses which also includes usage in commercial software without attribution.
@dr_laemmerbein @Gargron interesting... what for?
@rebeccafinn There are many applications. The easiest one is to sell your software without opening the source code to the public. One famous example would be the OS of the PS5. Sony uses FreeBSD as foundation for its OS, here are some other examples: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_products_based_on_FreeBSD
But for me the most important reason is that you should be free to do anything you want.
@dr_laemmerbein @Gargron This reads pretty tone deaf in this context of slave labor. Why permissive? So you can use slave labor without being caught?
Do you also feel slave labor itself is fine depending on "who defines the ethics?"
I'm pretty sure you had a point that isn't this. But it might need a bit more development for me to understand.