Who'd have thought? 😂
#ActuallyAutistic #AutisticExperience #Neurodivergent #Autism
Who'd have thought? 😂
#ActuallyAutistic #AutisticExperience #Neurodivergent #Autism
@KatyElphinstone Wait, they do?
@Catriona @KatyElphinstone I think this one depends very much on which they we're talking about here.
@KatyElphinstone From an NT perspective it can be one or the other or both.
@K2FI @KatyElphinstone can some more neurotypical people please share their understanding of this phrase?
For me (self diagnosed autistic), "hard" work has always related to discomfort, pushing limits. I wouldn't dream of calling something hard work that just "took one person a long time" or "required many people to get done" ("many man hours" in project management speak).
That's what "a lot of work" is for! Volume vs density! Arrr the longer I think about it, the less logical it becomes!
@lizzard @K2FI @KatyElphinstone It's only really used in that sense by people justifying a long-service benefit, as in "I worked bloody hard all my life for my pension". It's a bit of a running joke because you often hear it from sixty year old people who did nothing more strenuous than handing out stuff from the stationery cupboard.
@lizzard @K2FI @KatyElphinstone To me it means work that takes a lot of effort or endurance. So it can be either one. But the "effort" shouldn't cause actual pain and distress - that's not hard work, that's bad work.
@fullfathomfive
Same for me: I'm like "what work is causing you pain?? You need to stop it immediately!"*
*I'm aware not everyone has this possibility and a person has to eat, but it's not right damnit!
@econads
you're completely right, of course. But: I had to become 33 years old before learning that I have limits of mental distress that if ignored too long are actually unhealthy. I'm so used to being overloaded, and everybody else seemingly doing fine, and being told that I could do it if I just pushed myself - I genuinely can't tell anymore how much stress and exhaustion are okay.
I mean other parents have tough times, right? They collapse at the end of the work week from all the communication and organization that a school kid brings with it? But do they actually cry on most fridays? Is that normal? I don't know! because there's also weird social rules about not talking about these things apparently...
@lizzard
I used to cry about once a week from work stress, and I can tell you in retrospect that's not ok.
Don't worry about the others, look at yourself. Different people have different tolerance levels for different things and different skills, there's not really any such thing as normal IMO.
Do you have a partner who should be pulling their weight better, or friends who can help with one or two things?
I mean I have no experience of parenthood, so feel free to tell me to f off if this is unhelpful :-)
Mental distress is common in mothers overall but it is especially common in neurodivergent ones. What's expected of us is just too much. And it's invisible and, if mentioned, gets gaslit.
@KatyElphinstone
I'd suggest it's ok to break weird social rules if they're causing you distress. Normalising talking about it is probably a good thing..
@lizzard @K2FI @KatyElphinstone I agree with your definitions here. "Hard" work requires muscle and sweat.
(Also self-diagnosed autistic).
@lizzard @K2FI @KatyElphinstone I think anything that requires perseverance or that you'd really just rather not, the whole time or even just occasionally, must qualify as hard work. Where I'm from, a person can also be described as hard work if you have to try hard to be patient or civil with them. I am NT, as far as I know, and definitely hard work😆
@Iwillyeah Yes, this too! Anything you don't want to be doing or are unfamiliar with is harder work than something you like or are very familiar with.
Doing something you don't want to be doing for even a medium length of time is emotionally tiring. I would therefore count it as hard work even if the task itself isn't that difficult, because the energy you have to put in to do it is substantial and you come out of it tired.
Learning a new thing is cognitively tiring, and you come out of it tired.
It's the "come out of it tired" part that makes it hard work.
@Robotistry agree. Obviously digging a trench is hard work, but so is teaching an entire class where the only voice you hear is your own. Both are draining, though one you could do from a wheelchair and the other requires little cognitive input. I can't actually decide which I would prefer to do for a week. I'm exhausted thinking about them.
@lizzard @K2FI @KatyElphinstone For me (mostly neurotypical), "hard work" means something that takes a lot of physical, emotional, or cognitive effort. Something that (pre-long covid) would have left me drained but feeling accomplished. I might feel pain the next day, from overworking something (like muscle aches from a strenuous hike), but "hard work" itself does not imply pain or duration or number of people, only intense, sustained effort.
Discomfort might be involved, but it's discomfort at the level of "I had a good workout today" not at the level of "I went so far past my limits I was seeing stars and pulled a muscle".
@lizzard @K2FI @KatyElphinstone
I've never really thought about it before, but now that I do, I feel like there's this whole silent discourse on what "hard" means here. Like, I've heard it to mean physical labor, loke construction, but I've also heard it to denounce those jobs in favor of ones which require a college degree. It often seems to be moralistic, usually, talking more about the idea that someone earned or didn't earn something, which can be entirely subjective to the moment.
I think "Hard Work" is a nebulous phrase that means whatever we want it to in that moment, so I can see how some people would be confused by it. It might honestly just be a nonsense word, and I'm tempted to start asking people to define it.
@Raccoon good point. And as I read your post I started to wonder where you're from. Because morals and work tend to be intertwined in a very specific way in America, it being mostly protestant, and also with the specific flavor of protestants that see economic success as proof of being morally good. We have a similar thing in Germany, and I believe it comes from the post-war "Wirtschaftswunder" generation that has patterns where "doing your part for the greater good" was morally important.
@KatyElphinstone @lizzard @Raccoon
It's definitely something that can be situational from my own NT Jewish American perspective. It wouldn't be out of place for me to compliment a junior and thank them for their hard work when all they did physically was sit at a a computer and type. The hard work there is mental. But for my farmer friend, he's doing hard work raising pigs for market and my carpenter friend is doing different hard work building houses.
@KatyElphinstone Wait, what? O.o
@KatyElphinstone @bram WHAT?
@KatyElphinstone wait? really???? (not sarcasm)
@KatyElphinstone When did I asked for more proof that I'm probably autistic? :floofNervous:
@KatyElphinstone TIL 😭
@KatyElphinstone wait actually?
😂
@KatyElphinstone this image is exactly why i am scrolling fedi right now instead of doing the work i should be doing :blobcatnotlike:
@KatyElphinstone WHAT?!?!?!? TIL
@KatyElphinstone It's kind of hilarious how there are a dozen or so "what really NT folks think what?" replies and NO "wait ND folks think what?", not a single one.
Does this say something about Fedi population prevalences? Your followers and their networks? Maybe NT folks also think "hard work" means "work that causes actual pain and distress"?
@datum @KatyElphinstone It might speak to our gullibility, which is sometimes said to be an ND trait vOv
I'm not sure I agree it's 'neurotypicals" in general. I'm working class, I can see some classes seeing it that way, they expended energy, hence it was important 'hard energy". But, for people who have actually worked hard hands on job, no.
It's socialization too. Work over a signidicant duration of time = hard work, sounds corporate.
@KatyElphinstone This is absolutely fricking true.
@KatyElphinstone wait what??? does it actually refer to time duration?????????
Hah, I feel this. My brother does concrete construction, I type on a computer in the comfort of my home. There is nothing I can do to convince my brain that my work is not “hard” as well.
Oh, there are many different kinds of pain!
@chadgeidel my sister is a farmer and I feel the same way. If I didn't have to deal with all the people, meetings, and remembering to say the right things the right way to the right people I'd probably mostly agree that my work is not hard work. Unfortunately the computer work is probably 30-40% of the actual work that I do.
Uhm wait, maybe I'm not neurotypical?? 🤔
@KatyElphinstone in German 'harte Arbeit' usually means physical labor. It is also more rarely used to describe mentally challenging work which can take a lot of time (like programming for hours)
When someone just works a lot we say that ("arbeitet viel")
@KatyElphinstone I had always problems to imagine this "hard work" in an office.
In my head this need sweating and muscles.
I thought this is one oft this strange things people say sometimes, maybe to show that they are great 😉
Sorry for my english 😉
@KatyElphinstone I'll add this to the growing list of things that feel like a lie, but are probably true 😅
@KatyElphinstone wait what
@KatyElphinstone
"All your hard work" is loaded with power/class differential. It can have the same meaning as "I realize you were inconvenienced." While it's said by people unfamiliar with literal hard work, that's not always oblivious: "Thank you for doing something time-consuming and mindless that I would never stoop to doing myself."
Ooh yes, the patronising element had not occurred to me but I think you're absolutely right about this.
@KatyElphinstone @stevebrady When I use "Thank you for all your hard work" I am trying to say "I recognize that you put a lot of time and energy into a typically thankless and possibly invisible job that I sincerely appreciate you doing because you did a great job and I didn't have to worry about things getting done."
@KatyElphinstone there's literally 0 difference these days
@KatyElphinstone honestly figuring this out was a game-changer for me
@KatyElphinstone I thought it was both. Like, at the same time.
@KatyElphinstone Since our home was bombed, I have been desperately asking for your help to secure a new tent for my family. We are still staying with relatives, with no safe place of our own. I urgently need $390 to provide shelter for my family. Please don't leave us alone. Every $5 or $10 brings us closer to safety. ❤️https://chuffed.org/project/208485-give-waleeds-family-a-chance-to-live
Wait seriously?
@KatyElphinstone i'm autistic, and in my experience, it is both.
from my dad who is more immersed in the culture of people afflicted with normalness:
Both. It could be hard labor for a short time, repetitive tedious work, or mentally exhausting work. “Hard” could just refer to simply doing your best in this context.
i also checked a few dictionaries. wiktionary says it's something that requires a lot of effort, but doesn't specify how rapidly that effort is exerted. the merriam-webster's definition of hardworking says "constantly, regularly, or habitually engaged in earnest and energetic work". both of these could be used to insinuate that distress is good but don't necessarily say it.
from my personal experience, i have been told that i "worked hard" both on days when i did, and when i did not, experience distress from the work. it usually wasn't massive distress.
personally i think i'll continue not using the term "hard work" because it doesn't frickfracking mean anything.
@maypop @KatyElphinstone also in Cambridge:
https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/hard-work
> work that needs a lot of physical or mental effort:
> It was hard work on the farm but satisfying.
> Her colleagues admired her capacity for hard work.
> The boss thanked us all for our hard work on the project.
the question of whether that effort is spread over time or not is not answered by the term.
@KatyElphinstone it’s like the veil has been lifted!
So, 3 weeks of tinkering with electron optics IS hard work … (‘tis barely a challenge, m’lud)
But the 2 hours of unbelievably painful and difficult task of doing paperwork for my mothers nursing home IS NOT hard work … (when it’s plainly the most difficult thing I’ll do all year)
Here I am in opposite land again!