Login
You're viewing the functional.cafe public feed.
  • Sep 13, 2026, 10:05 AM

    @omixann

    I’d be happy with an argument (which would be consistent with case law) that said:

    If the outputs of a machine-learning system can be something that would meet the existing tests for being a derived work of one of the inputs, then the machine-learning system is a derived work of the training data.

    That would be entirely consistent with existing law and would make OpenAI and Anthropic liable for a few trillion dollars of wilful copyright infringement.

    💬 2🔄 10⭐ 30

Replies

  • Sep 13, 2026, 10:12 AM

    @omixann

    To add a bit more (sorry for the double reply):

    The EFF brief did not try to capture any of this nuance. It could have proposed tests for where on that spectrum you are. It could have argued that the interpolation between different works is a transformative step (though there is case law that says this is not the case if you don’t call the interpolation ‘AI’) if done with a sufficiently large data set. It could have made arguments about the size of the models versus the size of the input (note: the weights of ChatGPT are larger than a losslessly compressed copy of Wikipedia and Project Gutenberg, and compression ratios generally improve the more data you have).

    It didn’t do any of these things and instead made specious arguments about ‘AI’ being special and magic and totally different from almost identical applications of exactly the same technology.

    💬 1🔄 7⭐ 25
  • Sep 13, 2026, 10:27 AM

    @david_chisnall once again I hope my message wasn't understood as an specific endorsement of what the EFF said, but more of a reflection on the nature of LLMs and their interactions with law and society in general. I think they have their reasons to be dismissive on any support for copyright (given its current shape vs. what it was meant to be historically), but I'm more than willing to accept that's preventing them from making a better argument than a knee-jerk reaction.

    💬 0🔄 0⭐ 7
  • Sep 13, 2026, 10:12 AM

    @david_chisnall unfortunately I'm not in a position to support or contest this, so assuming your verdict is correct ("even setting a reasonable threshold, OpenAI and Anthropic must be violating it") I'd agree on the outcomes.

    Not like I'm rooting for these two anyway, like, fuck them, I could probably trace most if not all of my grievances with LLMs back to these two.

    💬 1🔄 0⭐ 6
  • Sep 13, 2026, 10:18 AM

    @omixann

    In the case for which this brief was filed, NYT’s initial filing showed that the chatbots would regurgitate almost word-for-word copied of NYT articles. So the test of ‘is enough of the input preserved in the model to appear in the output’ has already been met. The definition of a derived work isn’t binary, but there’s plenty of precedent that tweaking the occasional adjective is not sufficient to stop something being a derived work, so it’s easy for a court to conclude that the output is a derived work of the input.

    The question then is if A is fed to B and B produces C, and C meets the legal definition of being a derived work of A, then is B also a derived work of B? And, if so, does it qualify for fair-use protections?

    I’m not a fan of NYT or Disney either, but they’re on the correct side in this specific dispute.

    To be honest, I’d be moderately happy with a ruling that says the model itself is not a derived work of the input but any output might be. That would make the legal risk of using the output in any commercial setting unacceptable for any company.

    💬 1🔄 5⭐ 20
  • Sep 13, 2026, 10:23 AM

    @david_chisnall

    > In the case for which this brief was filed, NYT’s initial filing showed that the chatbots would regurgitate almost word-for-word copied of NYT articles.

    I won't argue against that, and I hope my first message wasn't an endorsement of that.

    > To be honest, I’d be moderately happy with a ruling that says the model itself is not a derived work of the input but any output might be.

    Oh, I actually like this one.

    💬 0🔄 0⭐ 7