@omixann
In the case for which this brief was filed, NYT’s initial filing showed that the chatbots would regurgitate almost word-for-word copied of NYT articles. So the test of ‘is enough of the input preserved in the model to appear in the output’ has already been met. The definition of a derived work isn’t binary, but there’s plenty of precedent that tweaking the occasional adjective is not sufficient to stop something being a derived work, so it’s easy for a court to conclude that the output is a derived work of the input.
The question then is if A is fed to B and B produces C, and C meets the legal definition of being a derived work of A, then is B also a derived work of B? And, if so, does it qualify for fair-use protections?
I’m not a fan of NYT or Disney either, but they’re on the correct side in this specific dispute.
To be honest, I’d be moderately happy with a ruling that says the model itself is not a derived work of the input but any output might be. That would make the legal risk of using the output in any commercial setting unacceptable for any company.