@vfrmedia @philcowans @mttaggart well, you find a solid lawyer as one of your first steps...
but yes, it's a significant barrier to entry
@vfrmedia @philcowans @mttaggart well, you find a solid lawyer as one of your first steps...
but yes, it's a significant barrier to entry
@ireneista @philcowans @mttaggart
I think even a basic hosting service for community organisations /could/ work, but you'd have to set clear boundaries on what it can and can't be used for *and* enforce them - (after all you wouldn't want the local Reform/Restore Britain group or the equivalent in other areas making use of the resources, or its no better than what Mullvad and others are doing and claiming its "free speech")
@vfrmedia @philcowans @mttaggart content policy enforcement is a trap though, if you build a mechanism it will be used against you
@vfrmedia @philcowans @mttaggart what we're hoping is of course that knowing the people involved is some sort of solution, but there's a specific type of adversarial modeling we'd need to work through, for how that sort of thing plays out after the usual asshat bad-faith bullshit and a few rounds of legal threats
@ireneista @vfrmedia @philcowans I don't have the full answer but for sure a component is that small services can and should show bad actors the door with haste.
@mttaggart @ireneista @philcowans
one problem is if the bad actor is stubborn and determined, it can be way more than a small group with limited resources is able to cope with, especially if the project isn't providing a full time paid day job for the people involved *and* legal protection for them..
I don't even get deeply involved in the existing community groups round here nowadays, due to the inevitable conflict and drama that occurs and that it turns out to be more stressful than my day job!
@vfrmedia @ireneista @philcowans Worth distinguishing external bad actors causing a headache and internal service users for which a provider may be liable. The latter is, I think, the bigger concern and novel problem for most in this proposal.
@mttaggart @ireneista @philcowans
keeping out external threats is normal cybersecurity stuff and relatively easy to deal with (same as making sure your car or house door is locked and carrying out physical checks or using CCTV if required) - but internal users could be more of a proiblem. Particularly if you are providing "private/secure" services and someone wants to use them for something that is blatantly illegal in your country..
@vfrmedia @mttaggart @philcowans the thing we always tell people to consider before creating a corporate entity
which nobody ever wants to do at that stage, and it needs to be then, for all the most realistic mitigations ....
is what will you do if the jurisdiction you operate in makes it illegal, five years from now, to be openly gay or trans?
@ireneista @vfrmedia @philcowans It's an important question, although I'd contend that, much like Mossad, there's no threat modeling against rapacious fascism—certainly not with legal means. Which is to say that yes, you are accepting the risk of targeting by a regime when you offer services, and members should understand that offering the service is no guarantee of safety from said regime.
@mttaggart @vfrmedia @philcowans so just to get a little more pointed about it
when that happens, if you're operating as a corporation there are only three options:
corporations exist at the pleasure of the state. there is no fourth choice.
@mttaggart @vfrmedia @philcowans if your plan is (2), great. carry on, just make sure you have enough money.
also, as an activist we know what the funding landscape for that looks like right now and it's grim AF
@mttaggart @vfrmedia @philcowans if your plan is (1) or (3), why did you go that route in the first place? it completely defeats the purpose
@mttaggart @vfrmedia @philcowans our personal conclusion is that any plan that's going to rely on a corporation as a legal shield is a bad plan at this moment in history
@mttaggart @vfrmedia @philcowans but as we say, we've had ... it must be close to a hundred iterations of this conversation, at this point
and nobody ever, ever, ever wants to be realistic about that at the outset. everyone wants to wave it off as a concern that if you have that problem, you've already lost, or it's for somebody else to worry about, or nobody could expect more..... regardless of how it's put, the proposed course of action is always denial
@mttaggart @vfrmedia @philcowans sorry to be harsh about that. we totally understand that people who are not in groups that will be the first targets for state-sponsored extermination are strongly incentivized to just walk away.
@ireneista @vfrmedia @philcowans Mmm, it defeats a purpose, and probably the noblest one. I'd say the reasons to decorpo are not limited to the extremes of resistance.
I don't think it's really fair to expect small groups to fight the state in that way. It's a risk you accept for other trade-offs.
@mttaggart @vfrmedia @philcowans what it comes down to is that as a visible trans person we're not really having the same conversation, which, we get it.
@mttaggart @vfrmedia @philcowans right and like, if you're trying to serve marginalized communities, that's inherently risky because people's existence is politicized and that's beyond their control
and if you're not, what are you even doing
@ireneista @mttaggart @vfrmedia - so I think my take on this is more community first, tech second. Like, if the output is basically a support network and a set of tools to help individuals and community organisations self host, then I think I'd be quite happy with that.
Or maybe the solution is lower level services, e.g. shared server management with tools to make it easy for individual users to spin up their own Mastodon instance on their own domain.
VPNs are possibly a bit of a special case, and maybe the DEFCON folks reached the right conclusion there when they decided just to support Tor.
@philcowans @ireneista @vfrmedia Yeah my thinking was more shared infra and the ability to spin up services for oneself. But I also agree that this is something akin to the size of old key-sharing parties. It doesn't scale—intentionally.
@mttaggart @philcowans @vfrmedia it's not scale that we're concerned about. scale is not the blocker we are identifying.
@ireneista @philcowans @vfrmedia I understand. That was more in response to the DEF CON conversation. I think and hope I understand your concerns.
@mttaggart @philcowans @vfrmedia yeah, we do think you do. sorry if that was intense, the feelings we're having are about us, not you, don't worry.
@ireneista @philcowans @vfrmedia Not at all. I deeply share your concerns, although I am not living them as y'all are. I wish I had better answers.
@mttaggart @philcowans @vfrmedia all anyone can do is our best 💜✊
@ireneista @mttaggart @vfrmedia - btw, there's this:
Which I think is the closest I've found. I also feel that https://toot.wales/ and https://join.cosocial.ca/ are somewhat similar in scope.
Tech-wise, there's https://coopcloud.tech/ - @coopcloud.
@philcowans @ireneista @mttaggart @coopcloud
things like that are definitely feasible, provided you set expectations to all users they aren't going to protect you from the NCA, so don't do anything on those networks that would attract them! (to be fair not /that/ difficult to do if folk are sensible)
@philcowans @mttaggart @vfrmedia that's where we're at, as well
we went and read the linked thread, it does agree with our own conclusions both for generic infra and for VPNs
@philcowans @mttaggart @vfrmedia but yes, your goals around community seem like the right ones to us, we just don't know how to do useful things with that
> "support network and a set of tools to help individuals and community organisations self host"
we have yet to articulate this with @coopcloud but i do believe we are going in this direction
the solidarity network is crucial to empahsise which goes beyond hollow top-down claims of "reuse" and "community"
unity upon strategic tool use has major benefits which stands in stark contract to the dominant reinvent the wheel tech hype cycles...
@d1 @philcowans @mttaggart @vfrmedia @coopcloud that's good to hear, and we definitely hope it goes well
@mttaggart @vfrmedia @philcowans yes, absolutely
@ireneista @vfrmedia @philcowans It's why you need a legal entity in front of individuals to mitigate liability. But there are costs
And it's a trade-off. You're paying for conscience and choice with risk.
@mttaggart @ireneista @philcowans
There's a similar discussion about this here and the issues involved (at least from a USA perspective)