OK folks, I rarely ask for tech advice because I hate being 'splained to, but I'm stuck in a google 2fa loop related to my broken phone and trying to log in on my backup phone.
I have tried all the 'try another way' options including my account recovery email and getting it to send a text to the backup phone with a security number. Which seemed to work but then didn't actually log me in, and sent me back to the 2fa screen to my old phone.