@luis_in_brief @tongpu @whack Alright, time for me to bite. Why would humans collaborate to set the direction of the software if it can be customised to their own needs like your phanpy?
" - You write a library, and publish it on GitHub: who cares? The AIs might discover it, and use it, but the operator won’t know you exist or did anything.
It’s not just “you can’t get GitHub stars or traffic to your blog”; rather, there is no sense of a common human project you can contribute to. There’s your own private garden of code, which you can grow infinitely in all directions with the help of AI, but you never have to leave the garden and go to the bazaar to trade with people. Under these conditions, it’s hard to care or do anything."
https://borretti.me/article/no-man-is-an-island
Going through your list: #1 great goal, but experienced programmers are all over reddit complaining that nobody understands the codebase any more. And LLMs won't either at a certain scale https://maevyn.codes/decoherence
#2 Yes they can be used to write better linters etc, but LLMs don't have the context window to independently discover best practices, see the futures example from The Decoherence Trap. Also https://mastodon.social/@jcoglan/117546092428574920
#3 Hot take: Not everyone is a good product manager. For their own personal use software, sure, but LLMs are so hard-trained to only consider the immediate user, not any broader context, that they are mostly useful only when driven by an expert. And to go back to the starting point of this post, FLOSS projects have been overwhelmed by slop contributions. How do you solve this new barrier to collaboration? Talking about how Firefox and Linux are banned from r/opensource ignores that the big projects had already developed processes to manage large amounts of contributions, how are LLMs helping with one-person XKCD 2347 github projects?
#4 is a moral question, plenty of others have covered this and while I have an idea of where I land, I think the anti-LLM argument (in FLOSS but also in general) can proceed on their practical harms alone
#5 Vibe-porting is definitely a thing I guess. But can you maintain something you don't understand? Vonnegut "Another flaw in the human character is that everybody wants to build and *nobody wants to do maintenance*."