PSA: if an internet search tells you that a specific IP should be blocked, but you find that the whole internet is blocked, ask yourself if you're maybe behind sslh, in which case it's localhost that you'll have to unblock. Took us both a couple of hours of hair pulling.
This was made worse by #NextCloud not logging this failure in any visible place (that we could find?), so we had to do lots of guesswork that involved grepping for strings and digging up several layers of source files.
