These normalizing, sanitizing desires manifest in many forms, some more easily decoded than others.
There is, for instance, the pervasive tendency to insist that the midterm election was all about affordability.
These normalizing, sanitizing desires manifest in many forms, some more easily decoded than others.
There is, for instance, the pervasive tendency to insist that the midterm election was all about affordability.
The affordability tale is an implausibly monocausal story that is weirdly sanitized. And that is precisely what makes it so attractive to the mainstream: It is a way to discuss American politics without having to center all the “unsavory” stuff: the racism, the extremism, the cruelty.
The impulses that explain why the mainstream discourse is drawn to the sanitized “affordability” tale are also providing fertile ground for the type of “democracy is fine/there never was an authoritarian threat/the MAGA agenda is actually popular” laundering from the Right.
A lot of people across the mainstream spectrum of American politics have been fundamentally uncomfortable with acknowledging the political reality of a deeply asymmetrical threat emanating predominantly from the anti-democratic radicalization of the Right.
The idea that a “both sides” framing is the only acceptable approach is so deeply ingrained that being forced to root for the Democratic Party has felt, to a lot of people who consider themselves to be “balanced” observers, just not right. They are eager to return to “normalcy.”
The instinct is to apply “normal,” familiar-feeling categories: Silly politics, partisan shenanigans, typical Washington dysfunction. Faced with the enormity of the authoritarian assault since January 2025, it had become less convincing, less “respectable” to approach politics that way.
But the desire to indulge in this sort of discourse never went away. A lot of people and institutions are all too eager to accept any normalizing, sanitizing, laundering interpretation of the election that allows them to yet again indulge in the comfort of “normal” politics.
They reflexively gravitate towards anything that is compatible with the “It’s the economy, stupid!” paradigm; they almost instinctively look for ways to undermine any interpretation that centers the struggle over democracy, authoritarianism, and extremism.
What is at stake here is not just whether or not we can agree on an empirically plausible interpretation of what happened in the midterms.
The understanding that now forms around the election will determine how we move forward.
It determines what efforts will be perceived as legitimate responses to the challenges America faces - and what the mainstream discourse will deride as partisan overreach.
It will either establish or undermine the political legitimacy of attempts to hold the MAGA government accountable.
It will help legitimize efforts to finally enact the kind of structural changes to democratize the political system the county so desperately needs – or discredit them as a harmful threat to “unity” and the “balance” between Team Red and Team Blue.
Don’t let the normalizers, sanitizers, and launderers dictate the path forward.
There might be an opening for real progress, and such opportunities are rare in history. America simply cannot afford to waste it based on a (willfully) misleading interpretation of the election.
More here:
https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/posts/2132d576-7d37-4c21-837f-f7f6d486c96a
@tzimmer_history See also "I don't care who started it" schoolroom justice. We're taught that there's never a bad guy in reality, that's just comic books (and maybe history, but only once everyone who was in it is dead).
Boy are the institutional media and politicians in for a surprise then.
We are enraged by the corruption, the finality and we want laws past that serve us. What we get out of Schumer is a Vichy accommodation of big tech everybody is livid about