rakoorakoo@blah.rako.space
Nov 19, 2026, 1:15 PM@wizzwizz4
> states are clever at making legal excuses for whatever terrible things they want to do
In this text Stallman doesn't think that the purpose of a State is to restrict freedom, but that it does so sometimes and it's terrible. Which, following this logic, means that States are generally good and can be trusted on to enforce freedom.
Of cours in real life if free software really freed people from harm it would be an enemy of the State and thus be illegal, impossible to defend under copyright laws. Which means that the freedom it wants to protect are whatever those that are available under States. Everyone's decision of freedom will diverge. But Stallman so clearly argues in favor of free army rather than no army, or free capitalism rather than no capitalism: his position on freedom is aligned with his position in society, as someone whose freedom is threatened not by States but by companies.
@dalias @lispi314
> states are clever at making legal excuses for whatever terrible things they want to do
In this text Stallman doesn't think that the purpose of a State is to restrict freedom, but that it does so sometimes and it's terrible. Which, following this logic, means that States are generally good and can be trusted on to enforce freedom.
Of cours in real life if free software really freed people from harm it would be an enemy of the State and thus be illegal, impossible to defend under copyright laws. Which means that the freedom it wants to protect are whatever those that are available under States. Everyone's decision of freedom will diverge. But Stallman so clearly argues in favor of free army rather than no army, or free capitalism rather than no capitalism: his position on freedom is aligned with his position in society, as someone whose freedom is threatened not by States but by companies.
@dalias @lispi314