Login
You're viewing the functional.cafe public feed.
  • Nov 9, 2026, 3:50 PM

    @civodul

    About GNU, my post had been written in the context of the 40th anniversary. The core is about “Free Software”, FWIW.

    About GNU Assembly, I’ve read the Social Contract 1.0 several times and it misses the point IMHO because it doesn’t start by the values. Worse, it does not speak so much about values – it could read the same about “Open Source”, no?

    About prior art, I think many also miss the point of the values and mainly focus on “freedom”. For instance, “Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software”, it reads: « These freedoms are vitally important. […] because they promote social solidarity—that is, sharing and cooperation. », and I think the bootstrap seed isn’t the freedom but the solidarity. The solidarity isn’t a positive side-effect of the 4 freedoms but the solidarity is what produces the freedom, so to speak.

    About « the “common strategy” approach is falling apart today. », nothing is very different IMHO, as you said it’s on the table since the early 2000s. Maybe the current feeling of misalignement is because the difference has always been confused or implicit, as explained here p4bl0.net/post/2022/11/Paradox (French)

    About posting the link 100 times and a bit more ;-), it’s because I feel we are running in circle that I’d like we cut in one way or the other. 😁

    💬 1🔄 1⭐ 1

Replies

  • Nov 9, 2026, 5:34 PM
    @zimoun@sciences.re
    About prior art, I think many also miss the point of the values and mainly focus on “freedom”.
    I agree so much on this, that my main political criticism of #RMS is indeed he based the #GNU project on the value of #freedom.

    I think his bias was likely due to his background as an Americam grown up under #ColdWar propaganda.

    Freedom, like Communion (or, in your own words, solidarity) is a strong social value that was used to justify the conflicts of the second half of 1900. It's a totalizant value that is still used to justify totalitarian systems like Capitalism just like Communion is used to justify Communism.

    In fact I'm afraid that RMS was successful because he provided a gentrified alternative to the hackers' revolution back then: the various old crews' attacks mined capitalism's credibility so they had to be stopped. On the other hand, Stallman founded a more palatable hackers movement that did not interfer too much with US business. Then open source was created to exploit that movement.

    But that revolution was worthy to be fought.

    The techno-feudalism that is rising from the remnants of late stage capitalism, could have been avoided back then.

    Anyway, the Stallman's error was to misredirect hackers focus from their core value, #Curiosity, to a fundamental but easy to exploit one (freedom).

    Curiosity requires both freedom (of thought, of speach, of research...) and communion (so that sharing with you what I've learnt or created, you can learn or invent new things I can then study and modify).

    But curiosity as a core value also provides a feedback loop that let freedom and communion find a dynamic equilibrium.

    A balance that no FreeSoftware license (nor open source) can provide.
    LLMs are just the latest of labor abuses created exploiting the hackers' naiveness that Stallman spreaded over years.

    That's why years ago I wrote the #HackingLicense https://encrypted.tesio.it/documents/HACK.txt

    @civodul@toot.aquilenet.fr
    💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0