@alexandra "The Free Software movement doesn't pursue the goal of "liberty for all humanity". If you think it does, you are gravely mistaken. Our goals are different, and are well described elsewhere."
this is a villain speech
@alexandra "The Free Software movement doesn't pursue the goal of "liberty for all humanity". If you think it does, you are gravely mistaken. Our goals are different, and are well described elsewhere."
this is a villain speech
@kyle_pegasus @alexandra that's so deeply disappointing
@Rob_J @kyle_pegasus @alexandra
"Ends justify the Means" ethical cowardice is always deeply sad.
@kyle_pegasus @alexandra and this isn't a libertarian position for sure
@dunklecat @alexandra of course it is, libertarians go back to the origin of liberalism. a person is merely property to them, and they have rights only because they own themselves. a slave has no rights because they're another's property, freeing one would be theft.
libertarians would be dangerous if not for their inability to pass themselves off as normal for long enough to convince anyone
@kyle_pegasus @alexandra what about anarchists? Where have you read about libertarian socialists pursuing a society where slavery is accepted? Pursuing a stateless society based on freedom and equity is all but a society where slavery has its place
@dunklecat @kyle_pegasus @alexandra There is a massive difference between libertarianism and anarchism.
@fogti @kyle_pegasus @alexandra I always find myself in a difficult position, as theoretically (and even for Wikipedia) anarchism is a (sort of) subset of libertarianism. Even anarchism has been used in one way and the opposite (there are people calling themselves anarco-capitalists that is the opposite of anarchism as it should be).
Thank you for your contribution
@dunklecat @fogti @kyle_pegasus @alexandra historically "libertarianism" was just a rebranding of anarchist communism but we've pretty well lost that fight in English. The lesson there should be that rebranding doesn't solve anything
@decay @dunklecat @fogti @kyle_pegasus @alexandra In French we have "libertarien" for the right-wing individualistic movement, and "libertaire" for the left-wing collectivist movement. In fact "libertaire" is almost a synonym of "anarchiste" while "libertarien" is quite the opposite.
For example, "communisme libertaire" is a thing but "communisme libertarien" would make absolutely no sense at all.
@p4bl0 @decay @fogti @kyle_pegasus @alexandra interesting, thank you!
@p4bl0
In German we distinguish "Liberale" and "Libertäre" in the same way. The party member of FDP (Freie Demokratische Partei) call themself "Die Liberalen" and represent the free market.
@decay @dunklecat @fogti @kyle_pegasus @alexandra
@gudu @p4bl0 @decay @dunklecat @kyle_pegasus @alexandra Tho I have never encountered anyone using the term "Libertäre" before.
@fogti @p4bl0 @decay @dunklecat @kyle_pegasus @alexandra
https://de.wiktionary.org/wiki/libert%C3%A4r
https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Libert%C3%A4r
But it seems not so clear or it give a widespreaded vocabulary comprehension. See this party: https://www.die-libertaeren.de/programm
@dunklecat @fogti @kyle_pegasus @alexandra
Sadly neither anarchists nor libertarians whatever the type cannot make exclusive claims to the use of their words.
I'm sorry to say these misunderstandings will happen when people care more about labels than ideas, otherwise they would be naming thinkers. There is a huge amount of political philosophy' on all of this.
@MrBerard @fogti @kyle_pegasus @alexandra I agree
@dunklecat @fogti @kyle_pegasus @alexandra in “ethics of liberty” murray n. rothbard explicitly endorsed slavery and ownership of children (up to and including trade in children); support for slavery is explicitly a libertarian position.
@mawhrin @fogti @kyle_pegasus @alexandra anarco-capitalist according to wikipedia, yep. It's not a strictly libertarian position, more of a capitalist one
@fogti @dunklecat @kyle_pegasus @alexandra I am starting to feel like these labels are doing more harm than good. I have some interest in justice and moral systems and every time I see a word like "liberalism", "neoliberalism", "libertarian", I need to google what it includes and what it doesn't.
How is a normie supposed to know who's on whose side?
Maybe people should describe what they believe in using a few short sentences instead? Break it down by major issues?
@martin_t @fogti @kyle_pegasus @alexandra I agree. Thank you for your insight.
PS I usually try to stick to Wikipedia's definition and explain what I mean when I feel necessary. It's not perfect but it seems to work most of the time. Here we have the additional problem that different labels talks about different aspect of the society and combining them provides very different society ideals.
@dunklecat @alexandra what about anarchists? why ask me? you brought them up. they have nothing to do with the conversation
@kyle_pegasus @alexandra I wish the @fsfe would make a public statement about this horrible take and where it stands regarding it. I want a free software movement I can be proud of being a part of, and this is not it.
@villares @kyle_pegasus @alexandra @fsfe RMS does reply in the thread, and it's substantially better. I still don't agree, but that's at least defensible.
@kyle_pegasus @alexandra If your rules lead you to side against human liberation, burn the rules.
@kyle_pegasus @alexandra I think we've had two centuries of hard lessons about the inadequacies of strictly deontological ethics, but some people have kept doubling down on it, beyond the point of absurdity.
@foolishowl @kyle_pegasus @alexandra
This sentence works with the word 'utilitarian' too, and whilst the time period may be shorter, it has been much more grievous.
Like how apparently okay to book the ocean to build the machine god, because, ...uh, it's not clear, it's not built yet.
So maybe the problem is strictness rather than deontology.
> in the Free Software movement, we only deal with evil that directly affects or threatens software freedoms
this is the line that got me
'software freedoms' has such a cop-tense ("man shot in altercation with police officer") feel to it. the idea that freedoms are detachable from people