Serious question to the US Americans:
In the context of activism, I keep seeing people urge others to "call/write your representative" as a way to effect actual change.
What confuses me is that it's not the usual performative people saying this, it's actually those who otherwise talk at length about how activism needs to be more than just voting and signing a petition. I often hear it from progressives or even self-proclaimed socialists.
It's generally portrayed as one of the most effective types of real activism you can do.
But from across the pond, I am just … confused?
Like realistically, how would contacting the representative of your region make any difference in their political behaviour whatsoever?
I have been involved in local politics myself here and, well, as politicians we already had an opinion on things. You know, that's why we were in politics and why we were organised in a party and all. People voted for us because of our existing stance on issues. We voted and worked in accordance with our party's stances, our programme and our ideology.
Most of our work would be about putting our view on things into practice. The voters only matter insofar as they either vote for our stance or they vote against our stance, and based on how much they vote in our favour, we have either a lot of power to do so or not as much.
If I was a representative in the US, why on Earth would I change my opinion on a political issue like abortion or cannabis legalisation just because enough people of an opposing side blow up my phone line or copy-paste the same damn e-mail into my inbox?
How would I explain that to my party peers? "Yeah sorry friends, I decided not to go ahead with the strategy we developed together … I got a lot of e-mails from people lately that told me to vote their way"? Huh?
If anything, it would probably be spam that gets in the way of my work, no? I mean, I am already aware of the different opinions my constituents hold. Them writing an angry e-mail at me to reiterate what they think does not offer any new information.
Over here, it would be ridiculous to go write at, let alone call your local representative. They already stand for something, that's what they got voted in for, why would they change their stance if their opponents just yell loudly enough at them?
Are US American activists just generally naive and stuck in a utopian dream where representatives actually try representing their populace and doing good by everyone, or does it genuinely just work differently in the USA for some reason?