Login
You're viewing the functional.cafe public feed.
  • Nov 5, 2026, 4:58 PM

    @evan@cosocial.ca they ran on holding big tech accountable. I fear the fediverse will be the innocent bystander hit by stray bullets, if you'll forgive my Americanism. It will be difficult to convince representatives that any increased liability should be proportional to the admin resources of a social network. They will see that as going easy on crime, because everything else aside, dems will always protect the state over individual liberties.

    There's also the issue of hosting costs. The mere proposal of regulation on big tech and AI could send capital markets tumbling. With silicon factories continuing today to turn more production toward gigawatt datacentes, an AI crash will necessitate huge amounts of capital for them to undo, right when it's least available. Compute resources would become even more scarce than today, which would increase hosting costs worldwide for some time.

    It's necessary to pop the bubble of course, and regulation is good and holding powerful people accountable is good too! But the idea that things get better the next day after doing that is a daydream. It's going to be a painful recovery, or transition, and instances in general will need more resources, moderation and financial, to get through I predict.

    💬 1🔄 0⭐ 0

Replies

  • Nov 6, 2026, 2:14 PM

    @amy @evan I agree with Amy here -- as the US, Canada, and others seek to regulate big tech (and they should!), they won't have the imagination to write laws that exempt or even encourage the growth of community-run social media. Big Tech also has strong enough lobbying that they may well end up crafting regulation that makes it harder for small systems to flourish. Democrats ran against Big Tech, for good reason, but their regulations may do harm to the fediverse.

    💬 1🔄 0⭐ 0
  • 💬 1🔄 0⭐ 0
  • Nov 6, 2026, 2:29 PM
    That's certainly a possibility. But we might have differing definitions of what "The Fediverse" is (obviously I'm not delusional enough to insist mine would be in any way more valid than yours of all people 😄).
    I don't think Meta or X can "join the fediverse". Using a distributed protocol os a prerequisite, yes, but the inherent "growth-above-all-and-at-any-cost" mentality of these companies makes them fundamentally ethically incompatible with what I believe to be the fediverse.

    And as others already noted no government so far (worldwide, not just the US) has shown any semblance of nuance regarding the scale of online entities. The mantra of everyone being equal on the internet has translated to single-use fedi instances being subject to the same requirements and regulations as platforms the size of facebook. I have little hope of that changing soon.

    All that said, having non-nazis win elections over proud nazis is always efinitely an overal improvement, even if a very low bar one.

    CC: @rwg@aoir.social @amy@ice.ch3.st
    💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0