Meantime on LinkedIn (thx @entreprecariat for pointing) Norman Nielsen circles brought the "user" back from the dead just to crucify it all over again.
it's always the user who is not fitting into their paradigms
Meantime on LinkedIn (thx @entreprecariat for pointing) Norman Nielsen circles brought the "user" back from the dead just to crucify it all over again.
it's always the user who is not fitting into their paradigms
On a serious note, together with participants of Reclaiming Interface Lab https://transmediale.de/en/programme/reclaiming-the-interface-lab we are extendnig my table of Subjects of Human-Computer Interaction https://contemporary-home-computing.org/turing-complete-user/#Subjects_of_Human-Computer_Interaction
At this moment the Agent is the Computer in the Agentic Web Paradigm.
"Dropping the “User” from “User Experience”
oops, we dropped the user again
But the biggest hypocrisy in this new NielsenNorman narrative is that AI agent is a user. Agent is an interface, or experience, as they call it.
Pattie Maes and Ben Schneiderman coming back to their 30 years old debate on Direct Manipulation vs. Interface Agents. Amazing session, question and discussion.
I leave it here to pin that even "mother of AI agents" is talking about them as interfaces and not users.
https://youtu.be/bzwajH4sWd0?is=SC-J9qMu4n-NOTzS
@GIFmodel @entreprecariat bit further now and they’ll discover semantic html
@GIFmodel so, in their paradigm, a user agent can also be a user user?
@GIFmodel as so many bytes are spilled these days over agents, I wish commentators would go back and read some of this long-standing debate and understand how long people have been discussing these ideas and (with some people) making very grand claims. (*remembers being in a class with Maes in 2005 and being told agents are just around the corner*)
Hopefully such a revisiting of the debate will get people to learn the history.
@GIFmodel its nitpicky, but if they choose "Experience" as their term and include "agents", what is the entity that... experiences?
@GIFmodel @entreprecariat Andrew Abbott writes that what professions strive for is abstraction; People are not abstract, so they are a bit of a problem.
(Status and Status Strain in the Professions, 1981)