Login
You're viewing the functional.cafe public feed.
  • Oct 31, 2026, 1:26 PM

    RE: mastodon.social/@tolmasky/1175

    Here's an interesting but a somewhat shallow take on #AI's impact on #FLOSS:

    LLMs have basically crowned open source the definitive winner over closed source

    The central thesis is that #LLM•s make it easy to copy any software and that completely eliminates the point of closed source.

    As far as functionality is concerned, P=NP. The “SSL” of closed source was broken.

    Maybe, to an extent.

    Everyone and their mother is shipping app clones. Note: it does not matter that these clones are junk. All that matters is that they have changed the way people feel about their software. They feel empowered.

    The might feel that way but are they? FLOSS from the very beginning had this idea of user empowerment but it hardly materialised. At its inception it was somewhat true that most computer users were also programmers but that changed and fast. Even just a decade down the road most computer users knew nothing about programming other than it exists. Only highly skilled people could wield that power. and with time fraction of those skilled people among all users diminished further and further.

    Right now most software users are not even competent computer users that know what a file is.

    Sure, it feels amazing that you can ask a chatbot for an app will pop out but those users are in no way equipped to maintain the app.

    it does not matter that these clones are junk

    But it does, though. Since the dawn of time we complain that software is crap and that software was made by professionals. Now completely incompetent people create equivalents of deep fried jpeg copies of software that barely pass first glance test. How do you think these "empowered" users will get frustrated by the bugs in their copies?

    This "empowerment" is also questionable for another reason. It only exists if you've got access to a decent model. You just can't get anything even remotely usable out of a 7B local model. So empowerment comes with a subscription fee. And once user cancels their sub they end up with a broken copy of broken software they don't know what to do with.

    This "empowerment" also eats the core of the cultural basis of FLOSS. You learn nothing when you vibecode an app. You don't exercise your curiosity. At best you get a dopamine hit because tings are happening. On top of that you do it alone. Vibecoding is extremely antisocial: it produces highly individualised software, there's just no community for that particular version, and it happens too fast for any sort of communal involvement.

    In short, users are paying for bad copies of software while they could've paid about the same for the original a little bit better thought through software. And most of these users don't care about the source code of the software in the first place. There's not much of a win here for FLOSS, not for the movement or the community anyway.

    💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0