Subject: AI of the past and present
For: S.F. fans and the “AI” debate
It isn’t a short analysis. I’m here, I’m detailed, and that is to be hailed and not derailed.
@mason said: For me in particular, I’ve been in love with the idea of AI since I was little. LLMs aren’t it.
In the 1960s and the 1970s, I used to read any book related to robots that I happened upon. It may have had to do with what I was, but I’m not certain.
“I, Robot”, Isaac Asimov’s 1940s series of short stories was probably the peak of the genre at the time.
Note: The 2004 “I, Robot” film has no connection to the Asimov series except for the title, the Three Laws of Robotics, and a few other bits.
The robot books and stories weren’t initially about how “AI” was going to launch us to the Singularity. [Charles Stross helped to introduce that theme in 2005 with “Accelerando”.]
The subtext and sometimes the theme were more about what it took for something that was created to be real and to have meaning.
In theory, the theme dates back to “Frankenstein” (1818). In practice, the first modern robot stories were probably “R.U.R.” (1920) and the original “I, Robot” story [by Earl and Otto Binder and not Asimov] (1939). Note: Asimov used the title “I, Robot” later as homage to the Binder story.
U.S. readers who are old enough might remember a 1964 “Outer Limits” TV episode about a robot [Adam Link] who was put on trial for his life. The episode, which is considered to be a classic, was based on the original 1939 “I, Robot” story.
From the age of single digits, I liked the Adam Link stories, Asimov’s robot series, Lester Del Rey’s “The Runaway Robot”, and the like. Asimov, too, wrote two of the best pure #AI [as opposed to #robot] stories of all time:
S1. “The Last Question” (1956). Multivac, the first true AI, is asked to reverse entropy and so save all life in the universe. Multivac and its descendants, Galactic AC and Cosmic AC, work on the problem for trillions of years. In the end, humanity is gone. In the darkness, the final AI states, “Let There Be Light”. A Big Bang takes place and a universe is born.
S2. “The Answer” (1955). This one is more of a shaggy dog story. In this story, the first true AI is asked, “Is there a God?” It responds, “There is, now!”
Stories about true AI as well as robots appeared intermittently for decades.
Charles Stross published an epic novel titled “Accelerando” in 2005 that was partly about a toy cat named AINeko who evolved over centuries into a god. Note: “Accelerando” has a Creative Commons license. You can read the novel online at:
https://www.classicly.com/accelerando
In a humorous note, after @cstross posted [here in the Fediverse] that modern “AI” was going to lead to a “Spamularity”, I responded with a fake book cover featuring AINeko in the “Spamularity”. Stross was angry because I’d used GenAI.
That was part of my introduction to the subject as it stands today. I’d been occupied with other issues IRL for a few years and hadn’t looked at what had been happening.
AI is about something real or real enough. #LLM and #GenAI are not it.
LLMs and GenAIs have applications. I used an LLM yesterday to get the site I’m posting on right now back up after a software update. However, the dismissal of ethical and practical issues is appalling and the “AI” mania as a whole is ridiculous.
See: https://dansu.org/ai-is-fake
It was bad enough that we didn’t get flying cars and “2001”-type space stations. Or even “Back to the Future” hoverboards. Now true AI has been set aside because a plastic toy version of it is available.
Better still, the use case is to give billionaires and, indirectly, Donald Trump, ICE, and any fascist government that manages to steal an election as much power as possible.
I’m probably going to spend the last few years of my life combing through the ruins of the economy trying to find a job that is non-existent because billionaires trucked it up.
Hooray. I’d hoped to focus on writing instead, but never mind that.
I might be going out on a limb here. However, it’s possible, just possible, that billionaires have enough money. It isn’t essential that they wreck the biosphere and the economy in a failed attempt to turn the rest of us into serfs.
In row 2 of the attached mosaic, the left 2 panels are both Astro Boy. He’s evolved since I watched the B&W 1st TV series in the 1960s. The latest take, “Pluto” (2023), is a dark murder mystery that gives Dr. Tenma a solid story arc after 65 years.
HAL-9000 [included in the mosaic] was supposed to be online in 1992. That was 34 years ago. HAL-9000 was a true AI, complex enough; conscious, conflicted, faithful up to a point, and murderous. He wasn’t a rubber duck that sounded a bit like a real duck if you happened to honk him.
“The Runaway Robot” (1966) is quite dated but is still good today for U.S. readers in Grades 4 to 8. I’ll post a copy with illustrations when I can.