Login
You're viewing the functional.cafe public feed.

Replies

  • Feb 26, 2026, 3:20 PM

    An example of metaphysical idealism can be found in @PugJesus@piefed.social’s post Here, on Piefed.social’s History Memes community. Here is the post in question:

    [🖼 lemmy.ml/pictrs/image/8cf81b60…]

    And here is the context provided by PugJesus below, in full:

    Explanation: A common argument of Soviet apologists is that everything the Soviet Union did was, in some way, dictated by ‘material conditions’, and thus necessary for the development of Socialism™. Obviously, this line of argument is dubious to begin with, but beggars belief when applied towards the Soviet Union’s instances of ethnic cleansing and genocide, which are either denied or so justified.

    Anarcho-Communists tend to be more critical of… well, everything. The CNT-FAI was an anarchist trade union which was one of the major players in the Spanish Civil War. After offering amnesty to all criminals to begin with a clean slate, they implemented work/detention camps for criminals convicted by local tribunals and fascist PoWs. Since prison abolitionism is a common cause amongst modern anarchists, they’re less willing to go to bat for ‘Good Team’ when it contradicts their basic moral code, even though the CNT-FAI is one of the most beloved examples of anarchist praxis in the 20th century.

    Let’s break this down.

    Explanation: A common argument of Soviet apologists is that everything the Soviet Union did was, in some way, dictated by ‘material conditions’, and thus necessary for the development of Socialism™.

    Nobody makes this point. Marxists seek to understand and explain why socialists made the decisions they’ve made. The reason for this is so that we can learn the true causes, understand the decisions made, and thus learn from their mistakes so as to not repeat them, while learning from their successes so as to apply when possible.

    The reason this is metaphysical and idealist is because the topic of the post, population transfer of Koreans, happened during the period of World War II, both its build-up and during the war itself. Paranoia was at an all-time high in the soviet union, and Koreans were suspected due to the highly reactionary dictatorship Japan had installed there as a part of their colonial project. As such, the soviets decided to forcibly relocate 170,000 Koreans from the far-east of Russia to Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan.

    For PugJesus, the reason for this is unstated, and context does not exist. The only explanation left for PugJesus is just “soviets did it because they were evil.” Not only this, but PugJesus therefore makes the strawman that Marxist-Leninists believe that every misstep of the soviet union was actually necessary and unavoidable. Population transfer is one of the most universally accepted mistakes of the USSR by most Marxist-Leninists, with some exceptions, but because we are dialectical materialists, we seek root cause analysis.

    The handling of the Koryo-Saram was a deep tragedy and mistake. It was not necessary for “building socialism,” despite what PugJesus believes Marxists think, nor was it done as a deliberate act to wipe out ethnic Koreans. It was a deeply flawed handling of a percieved problem based on real threats from Japan.

    Obviously, this line of argument is dubious to begin with, but beggars belief when applied towards the Soviet Union’s instances of ethnic cleansing and genocide, which are either denied or so justified.

    This line of argument is dubious because it does not exist. Nobody defends literally everything the soviets did, we seek to understand their achievements and mistakes in context, and the underlying causes. Further, the “genocide” and “ethnic cleansing” is left open, here.

    Anarcho-Communists tend to be more critical of… well, everything.

    Debatable, especially considering the strawman PugJesus made of Marxism-Leninism in general and dialectical materialism in particular.

    The CNT-FAI was an anarchist trade union which was one of the major players in the Spanish Civil War. After offering amnesty to all criminals to begin with a clean slate, they implemented work/detention camps for criminals convicted by local tribunals and fascist PoWs. Since prison abolitionism is a common cause amongst modern anarchists, they’re less willing to go to bat for ‘Good Team’ when it contradicts their basic moral code, even though the CNT-FAI is one of the most beloved examples of anarchist praxis in the 20th century.

    The interesting bit here is that PugJesus says the CNT-FAI made a “mistake” by imprisoning criminals and fascists, because of an idealist “moral code.” The reason the CNT-FAI developed prisons over the course of the war was because they learned that they needed them in the context of war, even if they sought to abolish them afterwards. This is an example of anarchists adjusting their theory after it ran into problems in reality, adjusting to it, and becoming more effective as a consequence.

    By understanding the context of the prisons, ie a brutal war, and their material causes, having a ton of fascists and criminals during the brutal war, we can see that this was a necessary step. By contrast, when analyzing the population transfer of the soviets, we have to question what may have happened had they focused directly on cracking down on infiltration of Japanese spies in the far-east of Russia, rather than relocating the entire ethnic group.

    It’s more reasonable when contextualizing the population transfer to recognize it as a mistake, but not one made out of a supernatural “evil,” and not one made for no reason, but due to deep suspicions on the eve of war. It was not necessary to handle the threat of espionage in this manner, and a number of other courses could have been taken. This is a mistake to learn from, while the prisons employed by the CNT-FAI were a strategic advancement on previous anarchist theory when waging open war.

    Dialectical materialism allows us to identify root causes. It is not the answer to any particular question, but tells us where to look and how to do so. This is the weakness of bourgeois historiography, the erasure of context and analyzing events and history as a “series of static snapshots” rather than an unfolding process leads to dramatic errors.

    Note: replying here rather than on PugJesus’ post itself, because both PugJesus and Deceptichum ban Marxism and Marxists.

    💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0
  • davel@lemmy.ml
    Feb 27, 2026, 4:59 AM

    Of course this showed on MoG.

    Grown-ass adults in the 21^st^ century still carrying moldy redfash brainworms.

    [🖼 lemmy.ml/api/v3/image_proxy?ur…]

    Didn’t need no welfare state
    Everybody pulled his weight
    Gee, our old LaSalle ran great
    Those were the days
    And you knew who you were then
    Girls were girls and men were men
    Mister, we could use a man like Herbert Hoover again.

    💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0
  • 💬 0🔄 0⭐ 0