Video player question for anyone who wants to weigh in:
From my personal perspective, I've never understood "Theater mode" as it exists in YouTube and PeerTube.
In the screenshots (showing PeerTube) you can see the regular player (first image) with the theater mode button [1]. In the second screenshot you see theater mode enabled, with a somewhat larger player area [2].
What I do understand about this is that it makes sense to have something between "normal player" and "full screen", i.e. a third mode that gives maximum viewing area *without* hiding your browser, window, OS interface, etc. (e.g. maybe you have another window next to it that should stay visible, or you want to see the time in your OS task bar, etc.).
But here's what puzzles me: Why is the viewing area in this theater mode as it is ([2], the red frame), and not the maximal viewing area that the page would offer ([3], the yellow frame).
If anyone has ideas/insights on that, happy to hear them! :)
(Context: I'm currently redesigning the video player in #Hyper8 and I'm planning four modes – in-page (default), full-page (somewhat like [3] in the second image), full-screen and cinematic viewing mode – but I'm eternally puzzled if and why theater mode is a thing and whether I'm making a mistake by not providing something like that :D)




