Login
You're viewing the functional.cafe public feed.
  • Nov 19, 2026, 7:39 AM
    retooted Daniel Kochmański

    @targetdrone @eniko

    The Gandalf analogy is a nice one :)

    I don't disagree; this automation is clearly capable and can achieve very impressive results. It is also much harder to criticize people who use it to break malware put on their devices, or to unlock something that they do own.

    GenAI as today deployed is only a new symptom of an old problem, where vulture capital executes its unsatiable greed impulses. Throwing something good, really cheap, is the hook; then they start to extract the value. Notice that Anthmorphic already started deploying "guardrails" against reverse engineering games for example. The wet dream is to capture 1-2% of the labor market, not to give people anything of value - because that's the only way to recoup expenses. That's about the motivation of the producer.

    Regarding the arms race with unethical crackers -- that's clearly a problem. And GenAI makes the discovery much faster[1]. That's a clear signal that we should work on more resilient systems, i.e not centralized on two servers on the internet[2] :). To express my view on this I need to put a distinction between:

    a) using genai to explore ideas
    b) using genai to implement
    c) using genai to communicate

    There is a misconception that step a) implies step b) and c). It seems easy: the automation engine recognizes the problem, implements the fix and communicates results. Given that we have regular exploits in the wild, it seems to be also more efficient than the alternative. What is the alternative?

    [1] Note though, that again, the capable systems without guardrails are available only to selected few under opaque rules with no accountability

    [2] But snarks, agreed, do not address the immediate problem. The immediate problem may be an impetus to rethink stuff many people take for granted - that interconnection and centralization is the future. Many people abhor IoT for a good reason.

    1/2

    💬 1🔄 3⭐ 5